The authors have contributed equally to the paper.
Quantification of biological or biochemical processes are of utmost importance for medical, biological and biotechnological applications. However, converting the biological information to an easily processed electronic signal is challenging due to the complexity of connecting an electronic device directly to a biological environment. Electrochemical biosensors provide an attractive means to analyze the content of a biological sample due to the direct conversion of a biological event to an electronic signal. Over the past decades several sensing concepts and related devices have been developed. In this review, the most common traditional techniques, such as cyclic voltammetry, chronoamperometry, chronopotentiometry, impedance spectroscopy, and various field-effect transistor based methods are presented along with selected promising novel approaches, such as nanowire or magnetic nanoparticle-based biosensing. Additional measurement techniques, which have been shown useful in combination with electrochemical detection, are also summarized, such as the electrochemical versions of surface plasmon resonance, optical waveguide lightmode spectroscopy, ellipsometry, quartz crystal microbalance, and scanning probe microscopy.
The signal transduction and the general performance of electrochemical sensors are often determined by the surface architectures that connect the sensing element to the biological sample at the nanometer scale. The most common surface modification techniques, the various electrochemical transduction mechanisms, and the choice of the recognition receptor molecules all influence the ultimate sensitivity of the sensor. New nanotechnology-based approaches, such as the use of engineered ion-channels in lipid bilayers, the encapsulation of enzymes into vesicles, polymersomes, or polyelectrolyte capsules provide additional possibilities for signal amplification.
In particular, this review highlights the importance of the precise control over the delicate interplay between surface nano-architectures, surface functionalization and the chosen sensor transducer principle, as well as the usefulness of complementary characterization tools to interpret and to optimize the sensor response.
Biosensor-related research has experienced explosive growth over the last two decades. A biosensor is generally defined as an analytical device which converts a biological response into a quantifiable and processable signal [
In order to construct a successful biosensor for the non-specialist market a number of conditions must be met:
The biocatalyst must be highly specific for the purpose of the analysis, be stable under normal storage conditions and show a low variation between assays. The reaction should be as independent as manageable of such physical parameters as stirring, pH and temperature. This will allow analysis of samples with minimal pre-treatment. If the reaction involves cofactors or coenzymes these should, preferably, also be co-immobilized with the enzyme. The response should be accurate, precise, reproducible and linear over the concentration range of interest, without dilution or concentration. It should also be free from electrical or other transducer induced noise. If the biosensor is to be used for invasive monitoring in clinical situations, the probe must be tiny and biocompatible, having no toxic or antigenic effects. Furthermore, the biosensor should not be prone to inactivation or proteolysis. For rapid measurements of analytes from human samples it is desirable that the biosensor can provide real-time analysis. The complete biosensor should be cheap, small, portable and capable of being used by semi-skilled operators.
Designed for the purpose, biosensors are generally highly selective due to the possibility to tailor the specific interaction of compounds by immobilizing biological recognition elements on the sensor substrate that have a specific binding affinity to the desired molecule [
Today, a multitude of instruments referred to as biosensors can be found in labs around the world and there is a growing number of biosensors being used as diagnostic tools in point-of-care testing, but the realization of cheap handheld devices is almost limited to one well-known example: the glucose sensor [
The whole area of biosensors started with the introduction of the first generation glucose oxidase (GOx) biosensor in 1962 [
Electrochemical biosensors have suffered from a lack of surface architectures allowing high enough sensitivity and unique identification of the response with the desired biochemical event. For example, pH and ionic strength in biofluids can differ significantly, which affects the response of important classes of biosensors such as immunosensors [
After introducing the many incarnations of electrochemical biosensors this review will discuss how electrochemistry has been and can be combined with complementary sensor techniques to enhance data interpretation. The latter we believe to be very important to optimize given biosensor designs and also for the increased use of electrochemical sensors to characterize biointerfaces. Emerging devices for electrochemical biosensors inspired by advances in microelectronics and nanotechnology like the biofield effect transistors, nanowires and other “near-molecular scale devices” will be introduced. The last part of the review will address surface architectures and modifications used in electrochemical biosensors to improve on sensitivity and biospecificity, as well as discuss the emergence of new devices from the multi-disciplinary field where nanotechnology, material science and biology converge.
Biosensor-related publications were sparse in the early 20th century. The early era of biosensing research and development was first sparked with the defining paper by Clark [
Since then, various forms of glucose biosensors have been developed, as well as many other sensing technologies and biosensing devices. This section attempts to describe operating principles of electrochemically-based biosensors by reviewing representative devices and their techniques from the aforementioned categories. Although the general topic of this review is electrochemical biosensing devices, a detailed overview is given in this section of various combinations of electrochemical sensing with other well-established sensing techniques and biosensor devices. Therefore, special attention is given to aspects of complementarity techniques and their advantage of independent, simultaneous measurements with (bio-)electrochemistry. A selection of specific biorecognition elements, structural components and various forms of surface architectures will be reviewed in the following section.
In biosensing the measurement of electrical properties for extracting information from biological systems is normally electrochemical in nature, whereby a bioelectrochemical component serves as the main transduction element. Although biosensing devices employ a variety of recognition elements, electrochemical detection techniques use predominantly enzymes. This is mostly due to their specific binding capabilities and biocatalytic activity [
Typically in (bio-)electrochemistry, the reaction under investigation would either generate a measurable current (
Since reactions are generally detected only in close proximity to the electrode surface, the electrodes themselves play a crucial role in the performance of electrochemical biosensors. Based on the chosen function of a specific electrode, the electrode material, its surface modification or its dimensions greatly influence its detection ability. Electrochemical sensing usually requires a
Synergies in nanotechnology and bioelectronics have revealed new possibilities to miniaturize and to optimize existing microscale devices at the nanoscale. It is becoming possible to more accurately measure specific electrical properties in combination with various electrochemical transducers. The higher surface-to-volume ratio of nano-objects makes their electrical properties increasingly susceptible to external influences, especially as these structures continue to shrink toward the atomic limit. Since the nanometer dimensions of these objects are comparable to the size of the target biomolecules, higher measurement sensitivity may result [
The direct determination of the analyte ion concentration with the Nernst equation is referred to as
Potentiometry is also used as an alternative method to electrically determine the point in a (bio)chemical reaction at which equal quantities of opposing solutions reach a state of equilibrium (
The construction of multi-analyte conductance biosensors and conductive polymer-based devices has been made possible by the rapid development of semiconductor technology and sensor integration with microelectronic devices, such as FET devices [
Voltammetry belongs to a category of electro-analytical methods, through which information about an analyte is obtained by varying a potential and then measuring the resulting current. It is, therefore, an amperometric technique. Since there are many ways to vary a potential, there are also many forms of voltammetry, such as: polarography (DC Voltage) [
The voltage is measured between the reference electrode and the working electrode, while the current is measured between the working electrode and the counter electrode. The obtained measurements are plotted as current
The shape of the voltammogram for a given compound depends not only on the scan rate and the electrode surface, which is different after each adsorption step, but can also depend on the catalyst concentration. For example, increasing the concentration of reaction specific enzymes at a given scan rate will result in a higher current compared to the non-catalyzed reaction [
Another amperometric technique is known as chronoamperometry, where a square-wave potential is applied to the working electrode and a steady state current is measured as a function of time [
This technique of chronoamperometry is, therefore, closely related to the Cottrell equation [
The first publication of electrochemical impedance spectroscopy dates to 1975 [
EIS possesses the ability to study any intrinsic material property or specific processes that could influence the conductivity/resistivity or capacitivity of an electrochemical system. Therefore, EIS is a useful tool in the development and analysis of materials for biosensor transduction, such as the study of polymer degradation. For example, by coating conductive electrodes with insulating polymers and then introducing this to an enzymatic reaction, the direct or indirect degradation of the polymer coating can be studied. If during the reaction existing free ions are able to penetrate into the polymer, the insulating nature of the polymer would be compromised and result in modified impedance characteristics of the transducing element [
For electrochemical sensing, impedance techniques are useful to monitor changes in electrical properties arising from biorecognition events at the surfaces of modified electrodes. For example, changes in the conductance of the electrode can be measured as a result of protein immobilization and antibody-antigen reactions on the electrode surface [
Interesting is also the use of impedimetric sensing to detect the binding state of DNA. In an experiment reported by Hang
Finally as a side note, Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy also shares the acronym EIS with the sensing system known as an Electrolyte-Insulator Semiconductor [
The FET is a type of transistor that uses an electric field to control the conductivity of a channel (
Although there are many different types of FET devices: MOSFET, JFET, MESFET, CHEMFET, etc., the current focus in biosensing applications is on ISFET (ion-selective field-effect transistor) and EnFET (enzyme field-effect transistor) devices [
One of the most popular methods for the construction of FET-based biosensing devices is the immobilization of enzymes at the gate surface of pH-sensitive ISFET devices, creating an EnFET. The method of enzyme-immobilization is a critical aspect of the device's performance and sensitivity [
Other than a few ISFET-based devices, mainly for pH testing, FET-based biosensors have not yet been successfully commercialized [
Another alternative in FET-based biosensing, which has generated an enormous amount of interest in the past years, is the use of nano-objects, such as nanowires or carbon nanotubes, in combination with FET technology. The use of nanowires in sensing applications is reviewed in detail in Section 2.2. Perhaps the most well-known and controversial work on the subject of nano-object based FET biosensing was presented by Cui
Nanowires belong to a growing family of nano-objects, which also includes
As a wire decreases in diameter to the nanometer regime, the ratio of surface atoms compared to interior atoms,
Assuming that the wire is free of impurities, the conductance of each channel is described by
Nanowires, therefore, represent very attractive bioelectrochemical transducer components since their diameters are comparable to the size of the biochemical analytes under analysis and since their conductance is sensitive to surface perturbations. As stated earlier in this review, nanowires have already been incorporated into FET devices for biosensing purposes, such as the detection of pH, protein and DNA binding, viral and cancer markers.
The successful implementation of nanowire-based biosensing devices depends on overcoming the challenges of their precise and reproducible placement in large-scale manufacturing processes, their specific biological functionalization, and their interconnection with both biological and nano-/microelectronic systems. Whether the nanowires are grown, pulled, tagged and enhanced, or deposited, the accurate characterization and subsequent controlled manipulation of the electrical properties of nanowires is essential to their application-specific performance.
Obviously, all sensing techniques demonstrate specific strengths in different, yet sometimes overlapping, areas of application. For example, both electrochemical and optical sensing techniques, can allow for real-time,
The following sections will provide an overview of the combination of electrochemical sensing setups with representative alternative biosensor techniques. We put special emphasis on the complementary data and enhanced interpretations that can be obtained, as well as recent advancements in the area.
In SPR configurations the surface between two mediums of differing refractive indexes is coated with a thin film of conducting material, which is often a noble metal, such as Ag, Au or Cu. If this thin film is irradiated by light of a certain wavelength at a specific incident angle, termed the SPR angle, the evanescent field wave from Total Internal Reflection (TIR) can excite an electron wave, known as a surface plasmon, which propagates along the metal surface [
For use as a biosensor, the changes in refractive index in the vicinity of the conductive thin film surface (
In EC-SPR, the combination of electrochemistry and SPR, the thin metal film on the substrate serves not only to excite surface plasmons, but also acts as a working electrode for electrochemical detection or control [
Waveguide based optical evanescent sensors have equivalent sensitivity to small numbers of adsorbed analytes compared to most other biosensors. However, because of the need for both, an optically transparent substrate and interface (electrode), fewer combinations of waveguide spectroscopy and electrochemistry to SPR and electrochemistry have been made, since optically transparent electrodes are rare. Optical Waveguide Lightmode Spectroscopy(OWLS) is a label-free technique that allows for
Electrochemical OWLS (EC-OWLS) combines evanescent-field optical sensing with the electrochemical control of surface adsorption processes. It gives the possibility to directly observe mass adsorption as a function of an applied potential [
An example of such a combined experiment is given in
Classic ellipsometry is focused on the external reflection of a light beam from a reflective surface, where linearly-polarized light of a known orientation is reflected as elliptically-polarized light. From the changes in the ellipsometric angles (Ψ, Δ), the optical properties, thickness, morphology or roughness of layers or films on the surface can be calculated [
Since ellipsometry can be performed on most reflective substrates it can be easily conducted on an electrode surface and combined with electrochemistry. Ying
The Quartz Crystal Microbalance with Dissipation monitoring measures changes in the frequency
The measured mass includes hydrodynamically coupled water such as water associated with the hydration layer of
By using a conductive surface coating or the working electrode of the crystal itself, QCM allows for simultaneous electrochemical experiments [
The main applications to date have been in the fields of polyelectrolyte multilayers [
The invention of the scanning tunnelling microscope (STM) [
Perhaps the most commonly employed techniques of SPM for imaging and characterization is Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) [
One area of investigation with generic EC-AFM methods is the study of electrode surface modification or performance under certain electrochemical conditions [
The development of ultramicroelectrodes (UMEs) and their combination with the SPM also paved the way for an SPM technique known as scanning electrochemical microscopy (SECM) [
Numerous hybrid techniques have evolved around SECM [
AFM-SECM is capable of obtaining simultaneous electrochemical and topographical information at high spatial resolution through the integration of an electrode into the AFM probe. In other words, the structural information is simultaneously correlated with chemical activity of the substrate [
Despite the almost automatic association of the words “magnetic” and “sensing” with Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), the focus of this section is the use of magnetism in combination with electrochemistry for biosensing. Therefore, some interesting transduction methods in magnetic biosensing use magnetic remanence and/or relaxation [
Discovered by Thomson in 1856, the magnetoresistive effect is the change of the resistivity of a material in response to a magnetic field. An illustrated overview of the use of the magnetoresistive effect as a general sensing mechanism, as well as a specific sensing scheme for the detection of pre-hybridized biotinylated DNA are provided in
In combination with electrochemistry Helali
In this chapter the different components of an electronic biosensor are discussed. It starts with the sensor surface that needs to be conductive and depending on the detection technique also transparent. A surface coating is to provide inertness and/or functional groups for tethering of the
Nowadays, a wide variety of different materials is used for the preparation of surfaces for biosensing applications. Depending on the measurement technique, they need to fulfill, special requirements, such as electrical conductivity for electrochemical techniques or transparency for optical devices. Most commonly used are glass and other oxide surfaces because of their favourable characteristics, especially their optical characteristics [
Electrodes are increasingly screen printed. This approach has advantages such as simple and low cost fabrication as well as easy mass production [
Another class of materials used for fabricating electrochemical biosensors are various conducting polymers. These include polyaniline, polypyrrole and polystyrene, which can be coated onto other sensor substrates. Typically, the polymers are adsorbed to gold surfaces. This leads to surfaces with good stability, excellent redox recyclability and easy handling [
Gold and other metallic surfaces are also coated with self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) of sulfides (thiols) and disulfides. Molecules with a thiol foot can form highly ordered and well-organized structures functionalized with an organic linker [
Carbon nanotube (CNT) modified electrodes have advantages in terms of their high surface area, mechanical strength, excellent electrical conductivity and good chemical stability. They are especially interesting because enzymes can be entrapped in the inner cavity [
In a more unique approach glassy carbon electrodes were modified with gold nanocrystals. Gold nanoparticles were then bound via cysteamine. The whole procedure leads to high efficiency of the enzyme immobilization [
Electrochemical biosensors are mostly based on the principle of direct transduction of the reaction rate into a current [
The drawback of this electrode setup is the dependence on the oxygen concentration which is difficult to maintain at a constant level. In the second generation, the oxygen was replaced by other, reversible, oxidizing reagents also known as
In general, it is preferable to have the reaction take place as close to the electrode as possible because the products diffuse in all directions, also away from the surface. This results in a decreasing signal with increasing distance to the surface [
Depending on whether a mediator is used or not one talks about
In biosensors that are based on direct electron transduction the redox enzyme acts as an electrocatalyst. They are also known as third generation biosensors. Such systems do not require a mediator. The surface immobilized enzyme selectively catalyzes the transformation of a specific substrate. The electrons are directly transferred from the electrode to the substrate molecule or vice versa as shown in
The direct electron transfer slows down with increasing distance between the enzyme and the electrode surface. This effect reduces the sensitivity of mediatorless sensors. Kuznetsov
In the indirect transduction the electron transfer mediator shuttles the electrons between the redox center of the enzyme and the electrodes (see
Mediators are small and mobile molecules, which are able to react rapidly with the enzyme. They are oxidized at the electrode and reduced at the reaction site of the enzyme or vice versa. Therefore, they should exhibit reversible heterogeneous kinetics, not react with oxygen and ideally be pH independent. Most commonly used are ferrocene and its derivates, ferrocyanide, methyleneblue, benzoquinone and N-methyl phenazine [
In a similar approach the mediator was replaced by carbon nanotubes (CNTs). Patolsky
Enzymes are proteins that act as powerful catalysts to convert substrates into products [
The most commonly used enzymes in biosensing are glucose oxidase (GOx) [
One of the major issues when working with enzymes is their stability. This includes shelf life as well as operational stability. Enzymes are very sensitive to their environment. Deactivation, inhibition or unfolding upon adsorption and chemical or thermal inactivation are common if no special precautions are applied [
Among other recognition elements, antibodies are most widely used because of the high specificity of the antibody-antigen binding. However, they are also very sensitive to their environment. In order to detect antigens, antibodies are surface-immobilized, which can cause a severe loss of their biological activity. Since the activity of surface immobilized antibodies depends on their orientation, it is advantageous to assure that they are not randomly oriented. Other reasons for inactivity include steric hindrance in cases where the density is too high as well as denaturation due to non-specific interactions with the surface [
Most commonly used is Immunoglobulin G (IgG) which, like typical antibodies, consists of one Fc and tow Fab' binding sites. It becomes inactive when the Fab' fragment binds to the surface [
Electrochemical enzymatic biosensors can be built up similar to the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). After immobilizing antibodies to a surface, an analyte is introduced to which the antibodies bind specifically. In the most common detection scheme a secondary labelled antibody then binds to the analyte in order to detect its concentration (see
A wide variety of antigens, usually in diagnostics, can be detected this way. It is
Nowadays, antibody fragments are emerging as credible alternatives to antibodies. They provide the same specificity as whole antibodies. Furthermore, they are smaller which can be an advantage for biosensor applications. In their main application field, biosensors and therapeutics, these small, highly specific reagents against target antigens are often used as bi- or trimers [
Most commonly used are IgG fragments [
Aptamers are folded single stranded DNA or RNA oligonucleotide sequences with the capacity to recognize various target molecules. They are generated in the SELEX (systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment) process which was first reported by Ellington [
The main application for aptamers is in biosensors. While antibodies are used in ELISA, the similar process for aptamers is called ELONA (enzyme linked oligonucleotide assay) [
Several different strategies for enzyme encapsulation to increase signal response and specificity have been envisioned and pursued. Some of the most interesting ones are reviewed below.
These microcapsules were first presented by Caruso and Donath in 1998 [
For applications towards electrochemical biosensing, enzymes can be incorporated into PEM capsules. This could be accomplished by adsorbing the enzymes inside the pores of the CaCO3 microparticles where their stability and catalytic activity was successfully maintained [
Liposomes or lipid vesicles consist of bilayer forming amphiphilic molecules such as palmitoyloleoylphosphocholine (POPC), called lipids. Liposome sizes vary between 20 nm and several hundred micrometers. Applications are in
Polymeric micelles are built from amphiphilic block copolymers. The inner, hydrophobic side usually consists of poly(acrylic acid) (PAA) or polyesters; for the outer, hydrophilic shell poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) is most widely used. Their size can vary between 10 and 100 nm [
Since encapsulated enzymes do not need to be mobile, hydrogels offer a suitable immobilization technique. Thus, cross-linked polymers form a biocompatible hydrogel that entraps the enzymes. The water soluble redox polymer should not cross-link too much in order to allow swelling in water. At the same time it mediates electron transfer between the enzymes and the electrode via electron diffusion through electron exchange between mobile polymer segments. In applications, such as electronic biosensors, it is important that the entrapped enzymes are not denaturated and remain in their active state. Otherwise, the sensitivity and selectivity of the biosensor is decreased drastically [
Like hydrogels, the sol-gel technique is applied directly on surfaces. In the first experiments porous SiO2 glass was used. Braun
Lipid bilayers can be used to build biosensors that make use of the transport process across the membrane. Functional lipid membranes have not yet found as extensive use in biosensor applications [
While most electrochemical measurements utilizing lipid membranes have been conducted using, so called, black lipid membranes (BLMs), which are formed across apertures separating two aqueous compartments, we will focus on lipid bilayer architectures stabilized by a solid support. Only these can be formed free from solvents and detergents, in a miniaturized format and with sufficient stability to be viable for commercial biosensor applications. There are recent examples of advances in combining nanostructures with lipid bilayers which effectively fuse the approaches of aperture spanning membranes with solid supported lipid bilayers [
Using SLBs to study transmembrane protein function or to construct the ion-channel sensors discussed below requires a lipid bilayer of high integrity to provide a good electrochemical seal. Without a good seal the current to the underlying electrode (or the impedance) is dominated by conduction through defects in the membrane instead of charge transport through the integrated proteins. Incorporation of membrane proteins like ion channels and pumps, which enable the diffusion of charged molecules, allows study of their transport properties through electrochemical measurements in configurations ranging from cyclic voltammetry to impedance spectroscopy and membrane-FET. Among these, impedance spectroscopy has been the most common characterization method due to the possibility to model the membrane from the impedance characteristics. To date, only a few membrane proteins have been successfully incorporated into supported lipid bilayers for electrochemical measurements, and they are mainly limited to small ion channels that insert easily in native conformation into lipid bilayers also when there is only a small aqueous reservoir between the lipid bilayer and the support. Examples of such peptides are gramicidin, melittin, alamethicin, and valinomycin [
Ion-channels in SLBs have also been exploited as a means of amplifying biorecognition events for electrochemical sensing [
The development and research of (bio)sensors is becoming one of the most popular scientific areas at the intersection of the biological and the engineering sciences. Semiconducting technology has matured so much that we see now a rapid infiltration of new nanotechnology-based approaches in the field of sensors. The resulting new discipline of nano-bio-sensing is a good example of how engineering sciences, physics, chemistry, and biology coincide at the nanometer scale: The traditional separation between transducers and bioreceptors is being replaced by an integrative approach as the nano-transducers start to take part in the recognition event and as the receptors start to become active transducing elements of the sensors (
Another explanation to why (nano)biosensing cuts out a major piece of the nano-bio cake is the need for it. Early, low-cost point-of-care detection of markers for diseases is crucial to diagnose and to manage health problems world wide, especially in the developing world. This has been evident already from the inception of the field when the need for distributed monitoring of diabetes mellitus was - and is - driving both academic and commercial efforts towards developing glucose biosensors. Nanotechnology now promises a solution for integration and high throughput for a vast range of electrochemical sensor applications. Miniaturization, functional sensitivity, simplified read-out and multiplexing are the answers for many current challenges of drug discovery and personalized medical care. In addition, nanotechnology provides new physical phenomena that can be utilized for sensing with a potential to reach the ultimate, single molecule sensitivity. For example, nanowires directly convert a binding event to an electrical signal (
Recently, gene-chip technology has become another prospering industry, which is growing at an impressive rate and opening new areas of application ranging from systems biology, drug discovery and forensics, to diagnostics [
In this review we focused on the interplay between the sensors and the corresponding transducer surface nano-architectures with special focus on electronic sensing. In the first section we introduced traditional electrical measuring methods that have largely contributed to the current advanced understanding of the existing transduction mechanisms. After this we discussed the use of field-effect transistor technology for biosensing with special focus on the efforts being invested into the combination of existing FET technology and nanotechnology, such as nanowires and carbon nanotubes [
As we approach the nanoscale, the characterization and optimization of the devices becomes more and more difficult. Novel tools that combine different sensing methods can provide the necessary complementary information that is needed to understand the limitations and to optimize the performance of the new techniques. Therefore, we introduced existing methods (
The enormous interest in microarray-based assays originally arose from work using DNA chips [
The various generations of enzymatic glucose sensors beautifully demonstrate the integration of transducers, biochemistry, and nanotechnology. In order to eliminate dependence on oxygen levels the mediator concept was introduced; later nanotechnology-based approaches help to overcome problems with low efficiency of the electron transfer between the enzyme and the sensor electrode (
Furthermore, supramolecular architectures enabled unprecedented signal amplification schemes,
Natural receptor schemes that operate at such low concentrations (
At present, biosensor research is not only driving the ever-accelerating race to construct smaller, faster, cheaper and more efficient devices, but may also ultimately result in the successful integration of electronic and biological systems. Thus, the future development of highly sensitive, highly specific, multi-analysis, nanoscale biosensors and bioelectronics will require the combination of much interdisciplinary knowledge from areas such as: quantum, solid-state and surface physics, biology and bioengineering, surface biochemistry, medicine and electrical engineering. Any advancement in this field will have an effect on the future of diagnostics and health care. Personalized and preventive medicine, bedside diagnostics, and drug discovery will all benefit from the novel electronic sensing technologies that were summarized in this review article.
The authors would like to acknowledge CCMX-MMNS-Nanowires project, CCMX “Platform for high-density parallel screening of membrane receptor function” project and the ETH Zurich for funding.
Elements and selected components of a typical biosensor [
A sample amperometric measurement: According to Kueng
The schematic and performance results of a potentiometric sensor for the detection of hybridization between complementary single-stranded (ss) oligonucleotides on the phase boundary PVC membrane/solution. The arrangement of the probe is shown in two configurations where the ss oligonucleotide is attached along (I) or parallel (II) to the PVC membrane surface. The potentiometric detection of the hybridization with complimentary strands is shown: (A) with complementary and unspecific interactions with non-complementary oligonucleotides; (B) with complementary oligonucleotides; (C) demonstration of the reproducibility after regeneration in a buffer of 0.01 M NaOH for 15 minutes (upward arrow) and subsequent injections of the corresponding oligonucleotides (downward arrow) [
An overview of selected cyclic voltammograms with reference to the work of Li
Chronoamperometric curves for detecting cholesterol in a phosphate buffer (pH 6.8), using Prussian Blue (PB) modified electrodes and cholesterol oxidase (ChOx)/PB sol-gel electrodes. The working electrode was polarized at -0.05 V (
a) i) Immunosensor for the in-plane impedance measurements between conductive electrodes, ii) interdigitated electrode for the in-plane impedance immunosensing [
Structure and principal function of a penicillin-sensitive EnFET. The enzyme penicillinase is immobilized on a pH-sensitive Ta2O5 surface [
Schematic diagram of a silicon nanowire FET [
i) A schematic representation of the design to use silicon nanowire FET as a biosensor for the label-free detection of DNA hybridization; ii) the change of resistance of the silicon nanowire array as a function of hybridization time ((1) 1.0 nM non-complementary DNA as control, (2) 25 fM, (3) 100 fM and (4) 1.0 nM target DNA in buffer); iii) the change of resistance of the silicon nanowire array as a function of hybridization time in 25 fM of (1) fully complementary, (2) one-base mismatched, and (3) two-base mismatched target DNA in TE buffer. The TE buffer solution (pH 8.5 10 mM Tris-HCl-1.0 mM EDTA-30 mM NaCl buffer) was used as the hybridization, washing, and working buffer. Reprinted with permission from [
An illustration to demonstrate the concept of the influence of surface interactions on nanowire conduction. In larger wires, for example with micrometer dimensions, the surface-to-volume ratio is relatively small. Even if surface interactions, such as binding with charge particles or biological species, influence conduction near the surface of the wire, there is still a large portion of the wire's interior available for uninterrupted conduction. To help visualize this, the illustration uses a mental construct of ‘conduction channels’ within the wire. As the dimensions of a wire decrease to the nanometer regime, the surface-to-volume ratio drastically increases. Therefore, the same external influences increasingly influence the conduction both on the wire surface and in the wire interior, thereby decreasing the possibility for uninterrupted conduction.
An overview of the experiment by Foley
The image on the left illustrates the sensing principle of nanowire-based biosensing with an FET configuration. The image on the right demonstrates the concept of multi-analyte biosensing with nanowire FET configurations [
Array of nanowires made from DNA-tagged Au nanoparticles using line patterns made with EUV-IL [
A modified schematic illustration of a combined surface-plasmon optical and electrochemical setup from Badia
Measured results of the biosensor of Kang
EC-OWLS flow cell. The laser is coupled into the grating at a certain incoupling angle. The ITO-coated waveguide acts as the working electrode, the reference electrode is placed on the topside of the flowcell and the counter electrode at the outlet.
A) EC-OWLS curve showing adsorption as a function of time. Additionally, the signal also reacts to an applied potential. Prior to the adsorption steps the system was electrically cycled to obtain stable conditions. PLL-g-PEG/biotin, neutravidin and biotin conjugated GOx were adsorbed in three steps with buffer rinsing in between. After completing the adsorption, a potential of 1 V was applied several times in order to measure the current generated by the enzymes at different substrate concentrations. B) Current after 10 min as a function of the glucose concentration. The applied potential was 1 V as stated on the left side.
An overview of an SPM technique combined with electrochemical techniques; a) SEM image and schematic top view of an AFM-tip-integrated frame electrode; b) schematic cross section of an AFM-tip integrated biosensor. Enzymes are shown to be immobilized at the surface of the scanning-probe tip-integrated electrode; c) schematic cross section of the experimental setup for imaging glucose transport through a porous membrane during simultaneous AFM mapping [
Topographic images obtained using constant-current mode of SECM imaging as presented by Kurulugama
Scheme of direct and indirect electron transduction. a) Direct transduction: the electrons only generate a measurable current if the reaction takes place close to the surface. b) Indirect transduction: with the help of a mediator, that shuttles the electrons between the reaction site and the surface, much larger distances can be overcome. c) Enzyme bound via conducting CNT. d) ELISA-like sandwich setup, where an enzyme labelled antibody binds to the detected antigen.
Schematics of supported lipid bilayer architectures used for sensor applications including electrochemical biosensors: a) hybrid bilayer, b) solid-supported lipid bilayer (SLB), c) tethered lipid bilayer (t-SLB), d) polymer-supported bilayers (pSLB), e) pore-spanning lipid bilayers (nano-BLM) and f) a nano-BLM with an incorporated protein for single channel recordings.
Upon becoming triggered to the open state, the pore filters and selects only those specific ions or charged molecules that are designed to pass through the channel [
Schematic of an ion-channel switch (ICS) biosensor as created by Cornell