Conceived and designed the experiments: DE EH KN. Performed the experiments: ADG RR AS CFS HJC GP RG DF VF EEP TP. Analyzed the data: ADG RR AS CFS LB MB PZ SdlP HGD DE EH TP KN. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: AS TP. Wrote the paper: ADG HGD TP KN.
The number of promising therapeutic interventions for Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy (DMD) is increasing rapidly. One of the proposed strategies is to use drugs that are known to act by multiple different mechanisms including inducing of homologous fetal form of adult genes, for example utrophin in place of dystrophin.
In this study, we have treated
These data indicate that 6 months treatment with arginine butyrate can produce modest beneficial effects on dystrophic pathology in
Long-term development of definitive treatments for DMD, addressing the problem of the primary defect by gene supplementation, repair or compensation are all relatively time consuming processes, especially in the eyes of affected boys and their families. For this reason, there is considerable interest in testing potentially palliative agents that are currently registered for clinical application. Since such agents do not address the primary cause of the defect, and our understanding of the pathology downstream of this primary cause remains inadequate, they have to be judged empirically in terms of beneficial and deleterious effects. Candidates for this class of therapeutic agent are selected largely for their activities in other pathological conditions and our speculations as to other actions on what we suspect to be the main pathogenic pathways in DMD. Given the uncertainties involved, it is important to scan for indications of beneficial effect and, perhaps more importantly, for signs of deleterious side effects across as wide a range as possible of outcome measures. In the case of DMD, most primary investigations of putative therapeutic agents are conducted on the
All mice were handled according to the local Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee guidelines. C57BL/10ScSn-Dmd
The study involved four groups of 15 animals each: (a) a control group dosed with 0.9% NaCl (I.P) (the vehicle for the arginine butyrate preparation), (b) a group receiving arginine butyrate at 250 mg/kg/day I.P., (c) a group treated with prednisone at 1 mg/kg/day (slow-release subcutaneous pellets), and (d) a group (referred to as the combination-treated group) receiving arginine butyrate at 250 mg/kg/day I.P and prednisone at 1 mg/kg/day. Mice were treated for 6 months, beginning at 3 months of age for 5 days each week (Monday-Friday) for 6 months. The arginine butyrate solution was stored at room temperature. Prednisone slow-release subcutaneous tabs (Innovative America, Inc) are available as a 90-day release formulation with a daily slow release of 1 mg/kg. Two tabs were used per mouse, with the second tab being implanted after 3 months.
Mice were subjected to a 30-min run on a horizontal treadmill (Columbus Instruments, Columbus, OH) at 12 m/min to unmask the mild dystrophic phenotype. The test was performed during the morning hours twice weekly over the course of the 6 months, except on those days on which functional data were obtained.
Rotarod tests were performed as described previously
Grip Strength was assessed using a grip strength meter consisting of horizontal forelimb mesh and an angled hindlimb mesh (Columbus Instruments, Columbus, OH). Five successful hindlimb and forelimb strength measurements within 2 minutes were recorded and normalized to body weight as previously described
Open field activity was measured using an open field Digiscan apparatus (Omnitech Electronics, Columbus, OH) as described previously
Five mice per treatment group were scanned at 9 months of age. Mice were anesthetized with 1–2% isoflurane in 100% oxygen and scanning was performed over 20 minutes using a high frequency ultrasound probe (RMZ 702a, Vevo 660, VisualSonics, Toronto, Canada) as previously described
At the end of the trial, all mice were euthanized, and tissue samples were taken for extensive testing as described below. A portion of each of the dissected muscles (e.g., gastrocnemius, diaphragm, and heart) was kept in formalin for H&E and Sirius Red staining. The remaining portion of each tissue was embedded in OCT compound and frozen in isopentane chilled in liquid nitrogen. Five non-overlapping representative fields of the tissue were imaged under a light microscope at an objective of 40× (high power field) and a digital image obtained using computer software (Olympus C.A.S.T. Stereology System, Olympus America Inc., Center Valley, PA). The digital images were loaded into Image J (NIH) with additional plug-in to count cells. Total number of cells, centralized nuclei, peripheral nuclei and total number of cells with centralized nuclei were counted and analyzed for comparison between treatment groups. Fibers showing degeneration (loss of striations/homogenous appearance of fiber contents) or regeneration (basophilic cytoplasm, large peripheral, or central nuclei with prominent nucleoli) and inflammatory foci per field were assessed in a blinded fashion as previously described
Briefly, serial 8–10 µm thick frozen sections were cut using an IEC Minotome cryostat, mounted to super frost plus slides (Fisher Scientific) and fixed in cold acetone for 10 minutes. Sections were blocked using 100 µl 10% horse serum and incubated with primary Laminin antibody (rat anti ms Laminin). After two washes of PBS sections were applied with Goat anti-rat Alex Fluor 488 (Green). After two washes of 5 minutes with 1× TBS slides were mounted using Vectashield mounting medium with DAPI.
The tissue was imaged under a fluorescent microscope at an objective of 20×and a digital image obtained. The digital images were processed using Axiovision software and minimal feret's diameter was measured. To obtain the actual micron size we set a scale using a microscope scale (Graticules LTD Tonbridge, Kent, England) 100×0.01 = 1 mm. The data were ranked according to size, the ranks were then normalized to sample size (rank number/total sample number) and the normalized rank was plotted on the vertical axis against fiber size on the horizontal axis. Kolmogorov-Smirnov test was used to assess difference among fiber size distribution.
Paraffin sections were stained with Sirius Red stain [Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, MO], and counter-stained with hematoxylin to visualize nuclei. The dye molecule intercalates into the tertiary groove in the structure of collagen types I and III and imparts a pink stain to most tissues when observed under white light. The tissue was imaged under a light microscope using a 4× objective, and a digital image was obtained using computer software (Olympus C.A.S.T. Stereology System, Olympus America Inc., Center Valley, PA). The digital images were processed using Image J (NIH), with an additional threshold color plug-in to process .jpeg images. The percentage of the fibrotic area corresponding to the area stained in red was compared to the total area of the tissue section, and the results were expressed as % non-muscle area.
For RNA isolation, gastrocnemius tissue (from 4 mice/group, totaling 16 mice) was frozen in isopentane cooled with liquid nitrogen. The tissue was placed into a tube with 1 ml of Trizol and homogenized. The total RNA was isolated and then cleaned using the Qiagen RNeasy Mini kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA) according to the manufacturer's instructions. The resulting total RNA was checked on a gel for RNA integrity and quantified using a Nanodrop ND-100 Spectrophotometer (Nanodrop Technologies, Wilmington, DE).
Gene expression profiling was carried out as described previously; using GeneChip mouse expression set 430 (Affymetrix 430 2.0, Santa Clara, CA)
Total protein was extracted from frozen gastrocnemius muscle by placing the tissue in NP40 lysis buffer. Samples were run on a 4–12% BIS-TRIS 15-well gel (Invitrogen) for 2–2.5 h at 200 V and transferred onto a nitrocellulose membrane for 2 h at 300 mA. Following transfer, the blot was stained with Ponceau red to determine the efficiency of the transfer. The blot was then blocked in 5% milk for 1 h and incubated with anti-utrophin (1∶100) (NCL-DRP2, Novocastra) overnight at 4°C, washed five times for 6 min each with Tris buffered saline, and incubated with horseradish peroxidase (HRP)-conjugated goat anti-mouse IgG secondary antibody (1∶3000) for 1 h at room temperature. Following another series of washes with TBST, the blots were incubated for 1 min using ECL (Amersham), and the blots were developed. The blots were then stripped and blotted for beta-tubulin (55 kDa) to assess equal gel loading. The autoradiograms were scanned using an Arcus II scanner, and volume analysis was carried out using Quantity One software (Bio-Rad Discovery Series). The ratio of utrophin to beta-tubulin was calculated for each group of mice.
Blood was collected by heart puncture immediately after euthanasia with carbon dioxide: 250 µL of blood was collected into Eppendorf tubes with no additive for serum separation, and CK determination was performed using a standard spectrophotometric method. Assays were carried out using the enzyme-coupled assay reagent from Fisher Scientific (CK10) according the manufacturer's instructions. Absorption at 340 nm was measured every minute for 2 min at 37°C to calculate the enzyme activity. Duplicate measurements were done on each serum sample.
Statistical analysis was performed by Student
The Kolmogorov-Smirnov test for equality of distribution was used to compare 6 parameters between mice under different treatment conditions (saline treated, arginine-butyrate treatment, prednisone treatment, and a combination of prednisone and arginine-butyrate). Each treatment was compared in a pair-wise fashion and the resulting p-values were adjusted for multiple comparisons using the Sidak method. A nominal p-value of 0.05 was considered statistically significant. All analyses were done using Stata V10 (College Station, TX). The differences were considered significant at a p value of <0.05.
6 months administration of arginine butyrate to
No statistically significant differences were observed in the weight of heart tissue of the drug -and saline -treated groups but normalization showed significantly increased heart mass in prednisone and combination treated groups. The weight of soleus was significantly increased in arginine butyrate treated (absolute) group in comparison to saline treated group, however normalized values of soleus weights significantly increased in all treatment groups in comparison to saline treated group (Supplementary
Both the forelimb and hindlimb grip strength decreased in all groups by the end of treatment, at 9 months of age (
Grip strength was measured using a grid at 3, 5, and 9 months of age. a) Maximal forelimb grip strength, b) The maximal hind limb grip strength, c) The normalized maximal forelimb strength, d) The normalized maximal hind limb strength of all the groups.
Examination of Hematoxylin and Eosin (H&E)-stained sections of gastrocnemius muscle of arginine butyrate-treated mice showed no significant change in total number of fibers, number of total central nuclei (refer to the amount of regeneration in a field) and number of fibers with central nuclei (fibers with centralized nuclei refers to cells undergoing regeneration cycle) number of degenerating fibers, regenerating fibers, peripheral nuclei, inflammatory loci and number of peripheral nuclei per high power field in comparison to saline treated group (
| Histology measurement |
FP0023 (N = 8) | Combination (N = 7) | Prednisone (N = 8) | Untreated (N = 8) |
| Mean±SEM | Mean±SEM | Mean±SEM | Mean±SEM | |
| Number of fibers/field | 78.61±6.62 | 70.90±6.08 | 69.06±8.24 | 69.27±5.05 |
| Central Nuclei/field | 54.31±3.81 | 46.19±3.79 | 46.56±3.76 | 46.61±3.01 |
| Peripheral Nuclei/field | 73.16±4.04 | 72.72±6.02 | 78.77±5.78 | 72.61±4.62 |
| Number of fibers with Centralized nuclei/field | 37.85±2.55 | 33.13±2.26 | 33.17±1.84 | 33.20±2.35 |
| Degenerating fibers/field | 8.25±2.84 | 10.25±2.53 | 11.38±2.41 | 6.50±1.71 |
| Regenerating fibers/field | 10.13±3.62 | 7.25±2.15 | 5.38±2.93 | 9.88±2.70 |
| Inflammatory foci/field | 2.13±0.85 | 2.38±1.95 | 3.25±1.52 | 1.13±0.55 |
# data was collected from 5 non-overlapping field from each sample and average of all samples within a group; * Analyzed as log (central/peripheral) using linear regression.
Since we noticed significant differences in body weight as well as muscle weight we decided to measure the fiber size distribution in all 4 groups of mice. The highest fiber size distribution (supplementary
| Group Comparison | P-value | P-value adjusted for multiple comparisons |
| Combination vs. AB | 0.004 | 0.02 |
| Combination vs. Prednisone | NS | NS |
| Combination vs. Saline | <0.001 | 0.001 |
| AB vs. Prednisone | NS | NS |
| AB vs. Saline | 0.03 | NS |
| Prednisone vs. Saline | 0.003 | 0.01 |
We then further evaluated the heart, diaphragm and gastrocnemius muscle of these mice for fibrosis by staining the tissues with Sirius Red. Fibrosis was significantly decreased in gastrocnemius muscle of arginine treated mice (p = 0.04) compared to saline treated groups (
Sirius Red staining of formalin fixed gastrocnemius sections from four groups of mice. A representative picture of each group is shown (A–D). Saline treated (A), arginine butyrate treatment (B), prednisone- (C) and combination-treated groups (D). Quantitation of fibrosis (% fibrosis) was carried out using the ImageJ program.
Sirius Red staining of formalin fixed heart sections from four groups of mice. A representative picture of each group is shown (A–D). Saline treated (A), arginine butyrate treatment (B), prednisone- (C) and combination-treated groups (D). Quantitation of fibrosis (% fibrosis) was carried out using the ImageJ program.
Sirius Red staining of formalin fixed diaphragm sections from four groups of mice. A representative picture of each group is shown (A–D). Saline treated (A), arginine butyrate treatment (B), prednisone- (C) and combination-treated groups (D). Quantitation of fibrosis (% fibrosis) was carried out using the ImageJ program.
At the end of the trial, we evaluated the heart function of the drug-treated and saline control groups by echocardiography. No statistically significant changes occurred in the ejection and shortening fraction of arginine butyrate-treated group (
Cardiac function was evaluated by echocardiography at the end of the trial. Both the ejection and shortening fractions (%) were evaluated. Error bars indicate +/− 1 SD. **p = <0.01.
Since arginine butyrate is known to induce the expression of fetal genes, including utrophin, we used Western blotting to detect utrophin in skeletal muscle lysates from the drug-treated and saline control groups. We saw variations in the utrophin expression among the arginine butyrate containing groups (
Muscle lysates from gastrocnemius muscle were analyzed by Western blotting using anti-utrophin antibody. Beta-tubulin expression was assessed on the same blot as a loading control. The autoradiograms were scanned, and volume analysis was carried out using Quantity One software. The ratios of utrophin to beta-tubulin were calculated for all groups. Error bars indicate +/− 1 SD. **p = <0.01.
mRNA expression profiling of gastrocnemius muscle from the drug-treated and saline control groups was performed using Affymetrix gene chips. To interpret the microarray data, we have used multiple probe set algorithms (MAS5.0, dCHIP difference model, PLIER). We have analyzed the data using GeneSpring software. Unsupervised hierarchical clustering showed arginine butyrate treatment drastically altered gene expression in skeletal muscle of dystrophic mice, followed by combination group and prednisone treated groups in comparison to saline treated group (
Temporal clustering of transcriptomes in arginine butyrate-, prednisone- and combination-treated mice and saline-treated controls. Signals were processed using the PLIER algorithm. Unsupervised hierarchical clustering (p<0.01) was done using GeneSpring Software (GeneSpring GX, Fostercity, CA). The data was normalized to the saline treated controls; yellow indicates normal; blue indicated decreased expression and red indicated increased expression of genes.
We found that genes that participate in multiple cellular activities such as focal adhesion, gap junction, hedgehog signaling pathway, Wnt signaling pathway, calcium signaling pathway, G protein signaling, striated muscle contraction, cell cycle, MAPK signaling pathway, mRNA processing binding reactome, cytokine-cytokine receptor interaction, adipocytokine signaling pathway, insulin signaling pathway, Jak-STAT signaling pathway, mTOR signaling pathway, regulation of actin cytoskeleton, inositol phosphate metabolism, glycan structures – biosynthesis, fatty acid biosynthesis, TGF-beta signaling pathway, PPAR signaling pathway, oxidative phosphorylation, folate biosynthesis, electron transport chain, aminoacyl-tRNA biosynthesis are differentially expressed upon arginine butyrate treatment clearly indicating HDAC inhibitory activity of butyrate
From the time of the discovery and characterization of the gene responsible for Duchenne muscular dystrophy, it was clear that rectifying the primary defect was going to be a challenge. Not only is it by far the largest gene known; too large to be encapsulated in the main viral vectors currently under consideration
The value of this rationale is well illustrated by the examples of the two agents we have investigated here. One, prednisone is currently ‘standard of care’ for those DMD boys who can tolerate its side effects, but no explanatory mechanism for these benefits has been firmly established. The second agent, arginine butyrate has the potential for beneficial effects via two routes, it makes arginine available as a substrate for nNOS, while the butyrate moiety modifies histones and has widespread effects on gene expression. Here again, the range of potential effector pathways is open to speculation. Our results from evaluating these two agents vindicates our general approach, for we have picked up quite different sets of benefits and dis-benefits from the two treatments, none of which would have been predictable from the existing literature on their biological effects.
In this study, we have taken a comprehensive approach to evaluating the effects of 6 months administration of arginine butyrate, prednisone, and a combination of both drugs on the disease phenotype in
Since body weight is a simple measure of the overall drug effect on the mouse phenotype, we measured body weight at different times during the trial and found that arginine butyrate had no significant effect on body weight, with arginine butyrate-treated mice showing a growth pattern indistinguishable from that of saline-treated mice. In contrast, prednisone-treated (1 mg/kg/day) with or without combination drug-treated mice showed a significant decrease in body weight. This prednisone-induced decrease in body weight and reduction of weight gain in
Grip strength has been extensively used to evaluate drug effects in the
We also assessed motor coordination using a Rotarod and found that the ability to stay on the Rotarod decreased significantly with age. It appears that none of the drugs we tested had a significant effect on motor coordination under these conditions. We also assessed the overall behavioral activity of the mice using an open field Digiscan apparatus and found that the animals adapted to the Digiscan apparatus over a period of time and generally performed better with time than they did at the initial time point. A comparison of the various treatment groups clearly indicated that the arginine butyrate-treated group generally showed lower horizontal activity, vertical activity, and total distance traversed than did the saline-treated group, but the combination-treated group performed better on all three parameters. The reasons for this poor performance on open field behavioral activity after arginine butyrate treatment are unclear; however, the positive behavioral effects seen with combination group were likely influenced by their reduced body weight when compared to the saline-treated mice.
H&E staining of skeletal muscle of treated mice indicated no significant changes in comparison to saline treated group. It is unclearly why the improvements in grip strength are reflected in improvement in histological changes. Since H&E is not useful for detecting fibrosis, we used Sirius Red, which has been used for many years to detect fibrosis
The arginine butyrate treated group have decreased cell size distribution in comparison to saline treated group probably due to increase in trend in fibers with central nuclei/field (regeneration) on the other hand decrease in fiber size is more pronounced in prednisone and combination treated groups correlating with increase in trend in the degenerating fibers on H&E sections.
Our results support the finding that L-arginine-treated
Although arginine butyrate has been reported to induce several fetal genes, we did not see any significant up-regulation of utrophin in the skeletal muscle of arginine butyrate-treated mice at either the protein or the mRNA level. In contrast, L-arginine treatment has previously been shown to induce utrophin expression in
Our results indicated that
The butyrate moiety of arginine butyrate has been shown to inhibit histone deacetylase, resulting in hyperacetylation of histones H3 and H4. Acetylated histones have a reduced affinity for chromatin, allowing chromosomal unfolding that can potentially modulate the expression of particular genes, including fetal forms of adult genes. This situation is consistent with our observation that 6015 genes were significantly altered in the arginine butyrate-treated mice, 972 in the prednisone-treated mice, and 1411 in the combination-treated mice. Our gene expression profiling data indicate cell proliferation, growth and differentiation as well as genes that control inflammatory, growth-promoting fibrotic genes are differentially affected by arginine butyrate treatment. Genes interacting with collagen deposition, abnormal inflammatory response and degeneration of fibers explain fibrotic effects of prednisone on the skeletal muscle. Likewise combination treated group regulated genes that contribute to muscle wasting and atrophy by inhibiting myogenesis, cell proliferation, interrupting cell cycle and impairing sarcolemmal localization of dystrophin. Further confirmatory experiments are needed to investigate the differentially affected gene pathways at protein level.
Overall, arginine butyrate treatment tended to improve grip strength and decrease fibrosis in the gastrocnemius. These data are supported by the increase in the expression of growth-promoting genes and decrease in pro-fibrotic genes that we observed in the skeletal muscle of arginine butyrate-treated mice. On the other hand, we did not observe significant changes in muscle histology; behavioral measurements, heart function or serum CK levels after arginine butyrate treatment. Detailed experiments need to be carried out in order to evaluate the effects of arginine butyrate treatment in younger mice.
In general, our state understanding of the pathological pathways and our knowledge of the range of possible effects of any given low molecular weight drug on these complex networks of pathways is quite superficial. In such circumstances, it is unwise to constrain analysis to functional effects on the basis of prior expectation based on our limited understanding of the action of these agents in other pathologies. The broad empirical approach we have used here has the merit of increasing the prospects of picking up unexpected beneficial activities. More importantly, such a broad survey also increases the probability of identifying unexpected ill effects such as the increased cardiac fibrosis associated with continuous administration of prednisone. This study highlights the need for comprehensive evaluation strategies to detect both beneficial and harmful effects any drug currently in therapeutic use or for which therapeutic testing is contemplated.
Comparison of individual muscle and organ weights of treatments in mdx mice.
(0.04 MB DOC)
Click here for additional data file.
Genes differentially expressed along with fold change.
(0.07 MB PDF)
Click here for additional data file.
Effect of 6 months treatment on behavioral assays: A) Rotarod testing. Open field activity (Digiscan)-B) horizontal activity. The combination-treated group (broken grey) showed a smaller increase in horizontal activity than did the arginine butyrate-treated (solid grey), prednisone-treated (broken black), or saline control (solid black) groups. The arginine butyrate-treated group showed less activity than did the rest of the groups. C) Vertical activity. All the groups except the arginine butyrate-treated group showed a progressive increase in their vertical activity. The arginine butyrate-treated group showed a decrease in vertical activity from baseline (3 months of age) to (5 months of age); the activity increased later but never reached that of the other groups. D) Total distance. While the saline-treated group showed a progressive increase in the total distance over the entire 6 months of treatment, the drug-treated groups demonstrated an erratic pattern. The arginine butyrate-treated group showed a decline toward the second month of treatment and recovery when compared to baseline at the end of the trial, with a statistically significant difference from the levels for the prednisone-treated group at 5 months of age. The prednisone-treated group did not change significantly during the trial. The combination-treated group showed an overall increase, with a small reduction at 7 months of age.
(4.29 MB TIF)
Click here for additional data file.
Fiber size distribution was evaluated by laminin immunoflourescence and minimal feret measurements. The data were ranked and normalized to sample size (rank number/total sample number). Normalized rank was plotted on the vertical axis against fiber size on the horizontal axis. Treatment groups: saline (blue), arginine butyrate (red), prednisone (green), a combination of arginine butyrate and prednisone (grey).
(3.28 MB TIF)
Click here for additional data file.
We thank Dr. Deborah McClellan for editorial help.