The growing conviction that lateral gene transfer plays a significant role in prokaryote genealogy opens up a need for comprehensive evaluations of gene-enzyme systems on a case-by-case basis. Genes of tryptophan biosynthesis are frequently organized as whole-pathway operons, an attribute that is expected to facilitate multi-gene transfer in a single step. We have asked whether events of lateral gene transfer are sufficient to have obscured our ability to track the vertical genealogy that underpins tryptophan biosynthesis.
In 47 complete-genome
Lateral gene transfer (LGT) undoubtedly occurs with high frequency [
Enhanced probability of LGT success can be expected if only a single gene is needed for the novel function. This does not necessarily rule out the acquisition of a new function that is complex and multi-genic. Sometimes where existing functions are complex and multi-step, a single incoming gene can create a new metabolic linkage. For example, an organism having a multi-step pathway for tyrosine catabolism could acquire a previously unavailable ability to also catabolize phenylalanine through import of a gene encoding phenylalanine hydroxylase (which converts phenylalanine to tyrosine). In cases where the total repertoire of multiple steps that define a novel function are all absent in a given organism, acquisition of that function by LGT would be highly improbable were it not for the existence of operon modules in prokaryotes. Lawrence has proposed, in fact, that gene organization as operons largely exists because of "selfish" properties that operate at the hierarchical level of genes [
Approaches for the detection of LGT events are either phylogenetic or parametric. Parametric approaches include the detection of nucleotide composition, dinucleotide frequencies and codon-usage biases in gene segments that are atypical of the recipient genome. Such parametric analysis is well illustrated by a study of the
Ubiquitous pathways of primary biosynthesis, having a long history of genomic optimization and metabolic integration, are generally improbable candidates for replacement by LGT [
Exceptions can be envisioned, among them: (
Amino acid biosynthetic pathways, such as the Trp pathway (see Table
Trp is biochemically the most expensive of the amino acids synthesized by prokaryotes. Accordingly, it is not surprising that Trp biosynthesis is usually regulated with fine-tuned precision. Different organisms deploy completely different modes of regulation, for example, compare those of
We refer to
This study is primarily a phylogenetic analysis and depends upon protein trees. However, sequences of proteins such as the Trp enzymes are not nearly as conserved as 16S rRNA, and it is well known that they are of limited value for making phylogenetic inferences over wide phylogenetic distances [
Additional daunting problems (which are minimal for 16S rRNA trees) assail the phylogenetic validity of protein trees. These are: (
Since particular lineages have optimized Trp biosynthesis to overall demands of primary and secondary metabolism that are both qualitatively and quantitatively individualistic, it seems that abandonment of native
Against this background of congruency (and, indeed, enabled
Figure
Individual Trp-protein domains vary in size and degree of conservation and thus confer varied amounts of phylogenetic information. Figure
The few exceptions that violate the otherwise good congruency between TCGs and 16S rRNA subtree regions point strongly to instances of whole-pathway
Orange-highlighted dashed lines in Figures
In the following section, individual protein trees are shown for comparison with the much superior tree of Trp-protein concatenates shown in Figure
Xie
TrpAa is the aminase subunit of anthranilate synthase. Figure
PhnA from
Figure
The •TrpAb domain of TrpAa•TrpAb or TrpAa•TrpAb_phzE fusion proteins showed similar tight clustering when comprehensive TrpAb trees were constructed (data not shown). We have suggested that a number of TrpAa•TrpAb fusions have occurred as independent fusion events, but that the sequences have then converged due to rigid constraints imposed for proper protein-protein interactions of these subunits [
TrpAb is the glutamine-binding subunit of anthranilate synthase responsible for function of the TrpAa/TrpAb complex as an amidotransferase. It is the smallest and least conserved of the seven Trp domains. Sequence features of TrpAb do not distinguish it from from PabAb, an amidotransferase subunit of
PhnB from
The gene encoding the TrpAb paralog (Sco_CDA) is a member of a large operon (along with TrpAa, TrpB, and TrpD paralogs) that is engaged in "calcium-dependent antibiotic" biosynthesis [
TrpB catalyzes the anthranilate phosphoribosyl transferase step in which anthranilate and PRPP combine to yield phosphoribosyl-anthranilate. In this paper the usage of "TrpB" refers to TrpB_1, the major and ubiquitous subtype species. The distinctly divergent TrpB_2 subtype is narrowly distributed (being cyanobacteria-specific) and usually co-exists with TrpB_1 in cyanobacteria (Table 4 [see
Figure
In the case of the unicellular cyanobacteria, a single set of completely dispersed
As observed above (Figure
TrpC catalyzes the phosphoribosyl-anthranilate isomerase step, which yields 1-(
TCG-5 organisms (actinomycete bacteria) lack a
HisA catalyses an Amadori rearrangement that is analogous to the TrpC rearrangement. This HisA isomerase catalyses the rearrangement of N'– [(5'-phospho
As noted above, the actinomycete group of HisA proteins is dually competent for both the TrpC and HisA isomerase functions, and they have been named PriA to distinguish them from the pathway-specific TrpC and HisA proteins [
TrpD catalyzes the reaction of indoleglycerol phosphate synthase, whereby CDRP is converted to indole 3-glycerol phosphate with the release of carbon dioxide (CO2) and water (H2O). The TCG groupings seen in Figure
All of the actinomycete bacteria (bottom of Figure
TrpEa is the alpha subunit of tryptophan synthase. It converts indole 3-glycerol phosphate to indole with the release of glyceraldehyde 3-P. It forms a tight complex with TrpEb [
TrpEb is the beta subunit of tryptophan synthase and condenses indole with
The TrpEb_1 sequences in Figure
The chlamydiae have an intact common pathway of aromatic biosynthesis, but none have a complete
The epsilon proteobacteria,
For comparison, we took a preliminary look at the histidine pathway in these four epsilon proteobacteria.
Fusions of general aromatic biosynthetic pathway genes, including those of the Trp pathway, have occurred frequently. It is not uncommon for the same genes in different organisms to have undergone fusion independently. In cases where the catalytic domains function separately, there may be great latitude for successful fusion orientations, for example,
The enzyme encoded by
Very much like the above situation, TCG-6
Figure
The ancestral
The ancestor of coryneform bacteria also imported a whole-pathway
It is interesting that
Another post-LGT event in
The
Perhaps the contemporary
The existence of a leader peptide associated with regulation of the
In the case of
Species of
The overall impact of LGT in
Gogarten
The above caveat aside, 16S rRNA trees do appear to provide a reasonable guide to the vertical trace of evolutionary descent [
It will be important to obtain other analyses of similar detail for other pathways to assess to what extent the evolutionary process that underpins Trp biosynthesis reflects the general process in other pathways. We have already seen in preliminary work that construction of similar congruency groups pertinent to common aromatic-pathway biosynthesis, folate biosynthesis, and histidine biosynthesis has good potential to expand the analysis. It seems probable that there are no prokaryote species whose evolutionary history exclusively involved a vertical line of descent for all of its genes. Lawrence [
Refer to the Gold Genomes Online Database [
16S rRNA subtrees were derived from the Ribosomal Database site [
Unrooted phylogenetic trees were derived from ClustalW alignment [
Multiple sequence alignments were derived by input of the indicated homolog amino acid sequences into the ClustalW program (Version 1.4) [
After each of the individual Trp-protein domain alignments were generated, both N-terminal and C-terminal unaligned regions were trimmed manually through visual inspection. Then the seven protein domains responsible for the Trp pathway of biosynthesis were concatenated in the order: TrpAa/TrpAb/TrpB/TrpC/TrpD/TrpEa/TrpEb. The resulting concatenated multiple alignment was used as input for generation of a phylogenetic tree using the program package PHYLIP [
Raw DNA contig sequences available from NCBI [
Fusion protein sequences from GenBank and NCBI Microbial Genomes Blast Databases [
The major roles of the authors were as follows. GX obtained the sequences, did the alignments, and obtained the phylogenetic trees. CB drew the figures. JS undertook the systematic management and organization of sequence data with the objective of achieving a dynamic and progressively updateable website. NK managed and coordinated the general laboratory operations. The initial guiding concepts and the initial draft came from RJ. All of the authors participated in the data analyses and in the formulation of conclusions. All of the authors read and approved the final version of the manuscript.
Table 4, entitled "Keys to sequence identifiers", is provided as supplementary material in an html document. This table contains a full collection of sequence data and annotations contained in this paper, and gi (gene identification) numbers are included and hyperlinked to facilitate access to the corresponding GenBank records. For future reference to a progressively updated table, refer to
Click here for file
This is Florida Agricultural Experiment Station Journal Series No. R-09802. R Jensen thanks the National Library of Medicine (Grant G13 LM008297) for partial support. Some of the preliminary sequence data were obtained from the Institute for Genomic Research [
Positioning of 47 complete-genome organisms on a 16S rRNA tree (phylogram view). Among these, seven 16S rRNA subtree regions are color-coded to facilitate comparison with the TCG regions on the Trp-protein concatenate tree of Fig. 2. Dashed lines in orange indicate organisms representing lineages where genomes of close relatives have not yet been sequenced. A grey box indicates a region of minimal current genome representation that is expected to become a region of subtree congruency. The subdivisions of the Proteobacteria are labelled at the lower right. Note that it is an idiosyncracy of tree presentation that Tfe and Xfa appear to group more closely with beta-proteobacteria than with other gamma-proteobacteria. However, it is a distance tree and close inspection of the distances reveal the identity of the gamma-proteobacteria as a single, cohesive group. The horizontal bar corresponds to 0.1 substitutions per site on the distance tree.
Phylogenetic tree (radial view) constructed using the seven-domain (TrpAa/Ab/B/C/D/Ea/Eb) concatenated sequences of Trp proteins that specifically participate in primary biosynthesis. The Trp-pathway concatenates are from the same 47 organisms shown in Fig. 1. Dashed, orange lines indicate the lineage positions of concatenated sequences from organisms that presently lack any close relatives whose genomes have been sequenced. TCG clusters are color-coded as in Fig. 1, where full bacterial names matching the corresponding abbreviations can be found. The Cje lineage, marked in aqua, represents a probable TCG grouping. Nodes marked with solid black circles are supported by bootstrap values of 100%. Concatenates of LGT origin within TCG-1 are outlined with a grey pattern.
Phylogenetic tree (phylogram view) of TrpAa sequences. Nodes occupied by a solid, black circle are supported by bootstrap values of 100%. Other bootstrap values are given within unfilled circles. Xenologs are shown with grey candy-striped bars, and paralogs are shown with lavender/white patterning. A specialized-pathway paralog from
Phylogenetic tree (radial view) showing that free-standing TrpAa domains, TrpAa components of TrpAa•TrpAb fusions, and TrpAa components of TrpAa•TrpAb_phz fusions are all distinct from one another. The position of some TCG groups are marked at the top. TrpA• fusion domains are color-coded to indicate their expected TCG placements if convergent evolution were not a factor. The TCG-1 grouping is distinctly divergent from all of the other free-standing TrpAa sequences.
Phylogenetic tree of TrpAb sequences. Xfa_2 is a probable specialized-pathway xenolog from
Phylogenetic tree of TrpB sequences. Det_2 is diagrammed with both patterns, indicating it could be either an ancient paralog or a xenolog. Sco_CDA is a specialized-pathway paralog (antibiotic). Asp, Asp_2, Npu, and Npu_2 are paralogs from a gene duplication that preceded speciation of Npu and Asp. The Asp and Npu sequences were arbitrarily used for input into the concatenate tree of Fig. 2. TCG-7 is fragmented. TCG-1 contains xenolog members of whole-pathway operons from
Phylogenetic tree of TrpC sequences. TCG-1 contains xenolog members of whole-pathway operons from
Phylogenetic tree of HisA sequences. Congruency groupings that match TCG clusters are labelled 'HCG' for histidine congruency group.
Phylogenetic tree of TrpD sequences.
Phylogenetic tree of TrpEa sequences. TrpEa proteins from Pae and Psy fall into TCG-3 instead of into TCG-2. Paralogs Asp_1, Npu_1, Asp_2 and Npu_2 were generated by a gene duplication that preceded speciation of Asp and Npu. Asp_2 and Npu_2 were arbitrarily used for concatenate input (Fig. 2). TCG-7 is not very cohesive.
Phylogenetic tree of TrpEb sequences. Cdi_2 is encoded by a paralog copy of
Schematic portrayal of two whole-pathway
Comparison of
Key to nomenclaturea used
| New gene name | Prior gene name | Protein domain encoded |
|
|
|
Anthranilate synthase: aminase subunit (α) |
|
|
|
Anthranilate synthase: amidotransferase subunit (β) |
|
|
|
Anthranilate phosphoribosyl transferase |
|
|
|
Phosphoribosyl-anthranilate isomerase |
|
|
|
Indoleglycerol phosphate synthase |
|
|
|
Tryptophan synthase, α subunit |
|
|
|
Tryptophan synthase, β subunit |
aThe nomenclature is at the level of catalytic domain in the order of reaction steps in the pathway. See [6] for a detailed rationale supporting the new nomenclature. Overall reactions of tight complexes are assigned one capital letter, with α and β subunits assigned the corresponding lowercase 'a' and 'b' respectively. The convention of a bullet denotes a fusion, for example,
Complete genomes where Trp-pathway genes were lost via reductive evolution
| Bacterial organisms | No pathway | Incomplete pathway |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | √ |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
|
|
√ | |
| √ | ||
|
|
√ |
aBut see [10] for a description of how an incomplete Trp pathway has been joined with other genes to yield a mosaic operon with a novel function. bInsect endosymbiont.
Membership composition of Tryptophan Congruency Groupsa
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| [ |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
aEach tryptophan congruency group (TCG) defined by the concatenated tree for Trp proteins (Fig. 2) is congruent with the color-coded subtree section within the 16S rRNA tree (Fig. 1). Organisms that are included in the concatenated tree of Fig. 2 are indicated in boldface type, whereas additional organisms not included in the concatenated tree but that were qualitatively determined to belong to a given TCG are indicated in regular type. bTCG members originating by LGT are indicated within brackets and indented. cInsect symbionts. dThe five organisms marked with asterisks form a distinctive subclade that is, in fact, not a "pure" component of TCG-2 because of the LGT origins of