Mucopolysaccharidosis type II (MPSII), or Hunter syndrome, is a devastating disorder associated with a shortened life expectancy. Patients affected by MPSII have a variety of symptoms that affect all organs of the body and may include progressive cognitive impairment. MPSII is due to inactivity of the enzyme iduronate-2-sulfatase (IDS), which results in the accumulation of storage material in the lysosomes, such as dermatan and heparan sulfates, with consequent cell degeneration in all tissues including, in the severe phenotype, neurodegeneration in the central nervous system (CNS). To date, the only treatment available is systemic infusion of IDS, which ameliorates exclusively certain visceral defects. Therefore, it is important to simultaneously treat the visceral and CNS defects of the MPSII patients. Here, we have developed enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) protocols in a mouse model that allow the IDS to reach the brain, with the substantial correction of the CNS phenotype and of the neurobehavioral features. Treatments were beneficial even in adult and old MPSII mice, using relatively low doses of infused IDS over long intervals. This study demonstrates that CNS defects of MPSII mice can be treated by systemic ERT, providing the potential for development of an effective treatment for MPSII patients.
The enzyme iduronate-2-sulfatase (IDS) removes the sulfate group from the glycosaminoglycans (GAGs), dermatan and heparan sulfates, and its absence or inactivity results in mucopolysaccharidosis type II (MPSII), or Hunter syndrome, a lysosomal storage disorder. The pathogenetic mechanisms at the basis of MPSII are still unknown. The block in the catabolic pathway of derman and heparan sulfates results in the accumulation of undegraded substrates in the cells and tissues of MPSII patients, with progressive cellular vacuolization and cell death (
The MPSII (
We have thoroughly characterized the CNS phenotype of the MPSII mouse model, where diffuse neurodegeneration is seen in different CNS areas such as reduced neuronal density, increased ubiquitination, severe gliosis and increased apoptosis; this phenotype becomes more severe with disease progression through life. The mice also show progressive degeneration of Purkinje cell neurons in the cerebellum (
Recently, we established an efficient gene-therapy approach to treat both the visceral and CNS defects in these MPSII mice. MPSII pups injected with the adeno-associated viral serotype 2/5 vector carrying human IDS cDNA showed full correction of the CNS symptoms and the visceral defects for up to 18 months after therapy. Furthermore, we demonstrated that the CNS rescue was due to the crossing of the blood–brain barrier by the IDS enzyme (
Enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) with recombinant human proteins has been used successfully in the treatment of some other lysosomal storage diseases such as Gaucher disease (
Both cognitive and neurological impairment is a devastating problem for patients affected by the severe form of MPSII. Many obstacles need to be overcome to develop a therapy to treat the CNS defects of MPSII patients; however, the quality of life of these patients would greatly benefit by the simultaneous treatment of their systemic and CNS defects. Up to now, ERTs have been largely inefficient to treat CNS phenotype in patients affected by lysosomal storage disorders, and this was mainly due to the presence of the blood–brain barrier and to the fast clearance of the infused enzymes from the blood.
In the present study, we demonstrate that systemic administration of human IDS to MPSII mice via ERT allows the enzyme to clear the GAG storage in the brain, to correct many of the neurodegeneration markers and to rescue the neurobehavioral CNS disease phenotype. Through ERT, we can strongly ameliorate the CNS defects, even when using a relatively low dose of IDS, and with both short and prolonged treatment times. Furthermore, we show the rescue of the CNS defects even in a group of old (aged 7 months and treated for 3 months) MPSII mice. These data open up hope for the treatment of MPSII patients exhibiting cognitive impairment.
ERT is the current approach to treat MPSII patients. To investigate whether systemic application of IDS enzyme via ERT can deliver enzyme to the brain and therefore prevent or cure the CNS degeneration, we implemented different therapeutic approaches. These were designed to identify the minimal IDS dose and the longest treatment-interval time sufficient to treat the CNS phenotype of MPSII mice. Thus we proceeded as follows.
(A) A group of adult MPSII mice (aged 2 months; (B) A group of adult MPSII mice (aged 2 months; (C) A group of old MPSII mice (aged 7 months; (D) A group of adult MPSII mice (aged 3 months;
During these treatments, IDS activity was measured in the plasma of all of the treated mice, every other month from T1 to T7 (months 1, 3, 5 and 7), at 4 h after the last injection. The IDS plasma activity was extremely high and was even higher than the activity measured in the wild-type control mice. Interestingly, also with the group D mice that received IDS for the longest time, after 7 months their mean plasma IDS activity was 8.7-fold higher than that of the wild-type control mice (Table Plasma IDS activities according to mouse treatment groups, 4 h after last treatment Plasma IDS activities according to mouse treatment groups, 48 h after last treatmentMouse treatment groups (treatment schedule; Sampling time for plasma IDS activity (nmol/4 h/mg protein) T1 T3 T5 T7 Controls Wild-type (untreated; 5) 350 ± 16.0 261 ± 14.0 233 ± 23.0 221 ± 11.0 MPSII (untreated; 5) 18 ± 0.5 16 ± 0.8 21 ± 0.9 19 ± 1.2 Group A MPSII + 10 mg/kg IDS (1–2; 7) 10938 ± 779 MPSII + 5.0 mg/kg IDS (1–2; 7) 7500 ± 447 MPSII + 1.2 mg/kg IDS (1–2; 7) 2790 ± 226 Group B MPSII + 1.2 mg/kg IDS (1–4; 7) 1810 ± 151 MPSII + 1.2 mg/kg IDS (1–7; 7) 1877 ± 136 Group C MPSII + 10 mg/kg IDS (1–2; 7) 9292 ± 611 6957 ± 557 MPSII + 10 mg/kg IDS (1–4; 7) 7471 ± 118 6459 ± 301 MPSII + 10 mg/kg IDS (1–7; 7) 6642 ± 389 6633 ± 390 Group D MPSII + 1.2 mg/kg IDS (1–7; 4) 2828 ± 198 2551 ± 215 2212 ± 26 1724 ± 193 Mouse treatment groups (treatment schedule; Sampling time for plasma IDS activity (nmol/4 h/mg protein) T1 T3 T5 T7 Controls Wild-type (untreated; 5) 350 ± 16.0 261 ± 14.0 233 ± 23.0 221 ± 11.0 MPSII (untreated; 5) 18 ± 0.5 16 ± 0.8 21 ± 0.9 19 ± 1.2 Group A MPSII + 10 mg/kg IDS (1–2; 7) 271 ± 74 MPSII + 5.0 mg/kg IDS (1–2; 7) 296 ± 54 MPSII + 1.2 mg/kg IDS (1–2; 7) 217 ± 38 Group B MPSII + 1.2 mg/kg IDS (1–4; 7) 105 ± 27 MPSII + 1.2 mg/kg IDS (1–7; 7) 116 ± 46 Group C MPSII + 10 mg/kg IDS (1–2; 7) 208 ± 11 192 ± 12 MPSII + 10 mg/kg IDS (1–4; 7) 204 ± 10 183 ± 10 MPSII + 10 mg/kg IDS (1–7; 7) 210 ± 30 156 ± 37 Group D MPSII + 1.2 mg/kg IDS (1–7; 4) 214 ± 90 216 ± 94 169 ± 46 159 ± 38
The treated mice (groups A–D) were then sacrificed at different times 4 h after the final administration of IDS of each treatment protocol. In parallel, the groups of untreated MPSII and untreated wild-type mice were also sacrificed. The IDS activities were measured in homogenates from their brains and visceral tissues.
Group A showed brain IDS activities that decreased in parallel with the concentrations of IDS injected. Interestingly, with the administration of the lowest dose of IDS (1.2 mg/kg), some IDS activity was still detected in the brains of the treated MPSII mice (Fig. IDS activities following ERT, measured in brain homogenates of untreated wild-type (wt;
In conclusion, in all groups of treated MPSII mice, and even in the adult MPSII mice treated with the lowest IDS dose (1.2 mg/kg) once every 7 days, the IDS activities measured in the brains were higher than those of the untreated MPSII mice. However, as expected, the IDS activities were much lower with respect to those measured in the wild-type mice.
We also tested the IDS enzyme activities in the homogenates from liver, kidney, lung, spleen, heart and skeletal muscle of the treated mice and the untreated MPSII and wild-type mice (groups A–D). The tissue IDS activities measured in the treated mice (for all three IDS concentrations injectedand for all of the intervals of time) were always higher than the activities measured in the untreated MPSII mice and were also higher, with few exceptions, than the activities measured in the visceral tissues of the wild-type mice (
Next, the brains and visceral tissues of the sacrificed mice were analyzed for GAG clearance by Alcian blue staining of the treated and untreated MPSII and wild-type mice. There was almost total clearance of GAG accumulation in the choroid plexus of the third and fourth ventricles and in the cortex and thalamus of all of groups of mice, with respect to the untreated MPSII mice (Fig. Representative GAG accumulation following ERT, measured by Alcian blue staining of sections of different brain regions of untreated MPSII (
These data show that GAGs can be cleared with both short and prolonged ERT protocols with a low dose of infused IDS in juvenile mice, and they can also be cleared in the older mice with higher doses of IDS infusion. Importantly, the GAGs were fully cleared in all of the visceral tissues (
We then wanted to determine whether we could measure IDS enzyme activity and GAG clearance after prolonged periods of time from the last IDS administration. Thus, to evaluate the residual IDS activity, a group of adult MPSII mice (aged 2 months;
Surprisingly, 4 days after the last IDS administration, we still detected IDS activity in both the brains and the tissues of the treated mice; in most organs (brain, liver, kidney and spleen), this activity was higher than that for the untreated MPSII mice (Fig. IDS activities and GAG accumulation following ERTin the brain and visceral tissue homogenates of 3-month-old mice sacrificed 4 days after the final IDS treatments. (
These data show that the IDS activity remains in the brain and the tissues for a long time at sufficient levels to maintain the clearance of GAG accumulation. For this reason, the administration of IDS once every 7 days appears sufficient to correct both the brain and the tissue defects.
We have recently shown that progressive accumulation of GAGs in lysosomes of neurons leads to severe vacuolization. In addition, we have seen diffuse neurodegeneration in the thalamus, cerebral cortex and brain stem, according to reduced neuron densities (decreased anti-NeuN signals) and to increased ubiquitin-expressing neurons. This was also associated with the triggering of apoptosis, as shown by TUNEL-positive signals in neurons of the thalamus, cerebral cortex and brain stem of MPSII mice (
Here, we saw a clear reduction in the lysosomal GAG accumulation, as showed by the anti-Lamp2 immunostaining that marks the lysosome storage that is massively evident in the untreated MPSII mice (Figs Representative analysis of the rescue of CNS markers in the thalamus following ERT, with untreated wild-type (wt; 3 months old; A and B) and MPSII ( Representative analysis of the rescue of CNS markers in the thalamus following ERT, as for ×Figure
As expected, there was only a small increase in the neuron density in the brains of mice of group C (Fig.
MPSII mice also showed increased numbers of activated astrocytes, as revealed by anti-GFAP staining. This was clearly ameliorated in the thalamus, cortex and brain stem in all of the treated mice (Figs
Together these data demonstrate that through ERT we can promote partial correction of the CNS defects; importantly, this holds true even for the treatment of the older mice. Indeed, these old mice (group C) showed clear amelioration of the marker phenotype even when treated once every 7 days. Importantly too, prolonged treatment (7 months treatment; group D) with a low dose of IDS (1.2 mg/kg) and with the longest interval between administrations (once every 7 days) also improved the CNS phenotype of these treated adult mice.
To confirm the presence of the IDS enzyme in the brains of these treated mice, we performed a co-immunostaining using anti-lamp2 and anti-human IDS antibodies with brain sections of MPSII treated mice belonging to all of the groups. We clearly saw labeling for IDS in the thalamus of the treated mice with all of the treatment protocols (Figs
Ultrastructural analysis of thin sections from the cerebellum of wild-type mice revealed electron-dense membrane structures with morphological features of lysosomes in Purkinje cells (Fig. Representative analysis (
We analyzed the Purkinje cells of the group C treated mice (the oldest mice) by ultrastructural analysis and found significant improvement of the above-described MPSII phenotype. Indeed, for all the IDS treatments, the average diameters of the lysosome-like structures decreased (although they remained greater than that in the untreated wild-type mice; Fig.
The mice in groups C and D underwent both the open-field and rotarod tests. These neurobehavioral tests were carried out only in these two groups of mice because the clear phenotype measured by these two tests can be seen only in MPSII mice from about 5 to 6 months of age ( Behavioral phenotypes following ERT, of 10-month-old untreated wild-type (wt;
We have previously shown that MPSII mice undergo a loss of Purkinje cells in the cerebellum (
These data show that by systemic ERT, the MPSII CNS defects can also be functionally rescued, confirming the value of this therapeutic approach for the treatment of MPSII.
To date, the only therapy available to treat MPSII patients is ERT, which is only effective to ameliorate certain systemic defects. Progressive neurodegeneration in the severe form of MPSII patients is a devastating feature leading to dramatic intellectual impairment in the patients. It is therefore very important to establish an ERT protocol that can ameliorate the CNS symptoms in addition to the visceral phenotype of MPSII patients. At present, MPSII patients are treated with an infusion of 0.5 mg/kg recombinant human IDS once a week (
How is this possible? Our data clearly show that the IDS plasma clearance is very slow, which might well be the reason why we can find the IDS in the brain even with low infused doses. IDS contains N-linked glycosylation sites, and the circulating enzyme is highly sialylated (
How the IDS crosses the blood–brain barrier and reaches the brain remains a mystery at present, and it will be extremely interesting to understand this further. Indeed, the stability of the IDS enzyme in the plasma leads us to conclude that it is an important parameter for the crossing of the blood–brain barrier by IDS. Whether high circulating levels of IDS are required for its delivery through receptor-mediated uptake or via different routes remains an open question.
β-glucuronidase fused to the HIV Tat peptide was shown to be taken up by absorptive endocytosis, which was mediated by binding to heparan sulfate on the cell surface (
In truth, however, whether these therapeutic approaches will indeed be sufficient to treat or prevent neurodegeneration in MPSII patients is difficult to predict at present. First of all, patients are currently treated when the disease is already clearly manifest, and secondly, and unfortunately, they can also show high and variable immune responses against the infused IDS (
In conclusion, these studies clearly show that the systemic infusion of IDS in MPSII mice is an effective treatment for the CNS phenotype, and this work now opens up hope for effective treatment and/or prevention of the CNS defects in young and adult MPSII patients.
Female heterozygous MPSII mice were used, as described previously (
Blood (50 µl) was collected in EDTA at different times after the injections (months 1, 3, 5 and 7; T1, T3, T5 and T7) of the treated mice and the untreated MPSII (
The tissues for analysis were homogenized in water. Serum and tissue protein concentrations were determined using the Bio-Rad colorimetric assay (Bio-Rad, Hercules, CA, USA). The IDS assay was performed as described previously (
After the perfusion of the mice with PBS, the tissues were collected and fixed in methacarn solution (30% chloroform, 60% methanol and 10% acetic acid) for 24 h at 4°C. The next day, the tissues were embedded in paraffin (Sigma-Aldrich) after their dehydration through a 70–100% ethanol gradient. Finally, the tissues were sectioned into 7 µm thick serial sections. The tissue sections were stained with 1% Alcian blue (Sigma-Aldrich) in hydrochloric acid. The counterstaining was performed for 2 min with Nuclear-Fast red (Sigma-Aldrich).
Mice brains were collected after PBS perfusion and fixed with 10% neutral buffered formalin, pH 7.0, for 12 h at 4°C. Then the brains were embedded in paraffin (Sigma-Aldrich) and dehydrated through a 70–100% ethanol gradient. Immunohistochemistry and immunofluorescence analyses were performed on 7 µm thick serial sections. The specimens were incubated for 1 h with blocking solution [Tris-buffered saline, 0.2% Tween-20 (Sigma-Aldrich) and 10% normal horse serum, Vectastain Elite ABC kit] before incubation overnight with the primary antibodies.
For immunohistochemistry analyses of Lamp2 and ubiquitin of the paraffin-embedded, formalin-fixed brains, the avidin-biotin complex (ABC) method was used (Vectastain Elite ABC kit). A monoclonal rat antibody against murine Lamp2 (diluted 1:100; Santa Cruz Biotechnology, Inc., CA, USA) and a polyclonal rabbit antibody against murine ubiquitin (diluted 1:50; Abcam, Cambridge, UK) were used. Then, secondary biotinylated horse anti-rat and anti-rabbit IgG and streptavidin–biotin–peroxidase complex (Vectastain Elite ABC kit) were used for 1 h of incubation (for anti-Lamp2 and ubiquitin). The color was developed using the ABC Elite Vector Staining kit and the horseradish peroxidase substrate (Vector Laboratories, Inc., Burlingame, CA, USA). For the detection of apoptotic cells in the brain sections, TUNEL staining kits (Chemicon International) were used, according to the manufacturer's instructions.
Immunofluorescence analyses were carried out for the detection of NeuN, GFAP and CD68 (
The cerebellum was excised from 10-month-old treated mice and untreated MPSII and wild-type mice and fixed in 1% glutaraldehyde in 0.2
Urine from individual mice was collected in metabolic cages at the end of each treatment and from the untreated MPSII and wild-type mice. GAG levels in the urine were determined using the dimethylmethylene-blue-based spectrophotometry of GAGs (
The motor and the exploratory behaviors of treated mice were assessed in an acrylic open arena, as described previously (
The rotarod test is designed to assess the sensory motor coordination, balance, equilibrium and motor learning. The treated mice and the untreated MPSII and wild-type mice were placed on top of the rotating rod facing away from the experimenter, in the orientation opposite to that of the rod rotation. The latency times for the mice to fall from the rod were recorded automatically by the apparatus. For the first day of the test, the mice were placed on the rotating rod set at the steady slow speed of 4 rpm and trained to remain on the rod for 60 s. After this habituation trial, each mouse was tested in four trials per day, for 3 consecutive days, with an inter-trial interval of 30 min. The rotarod apparatus (Ugo Basile, Italy) accelerates gradually from 4to 40 rpm. The cut-off time was 600 s for the trials.
The statistical significance was determined for the measurements compared by the analysis of variance (ANOVA) test.
This work was supported by Shire Human Genetic Therapies, Inc., by the
The authors thank Alicia Gómez-Yafal (Shire Human Genetic Therapies, Inc.) for her strong support and critical comments to this work for the entire duration of the project. We also would like to thank Andrea Ballabio and Giancarlo Parenti for critical comments on the manuscript. We also thank Ivan Solombrino for technical support. We would also like to acknowledge Telethon Electron Microscopy Core Facility (Grant no. GTF08001) and IGB Microscopy Facility for the assistance with the EM analysis and Anastasia V. Egorova for the EM specimen preparation.