In cystic fibrosis (CF) respiratory failure caused by progressive airway obstruction and tissue damage is primarily a result of the aberrant inflammatory responses to lung infections with
Cystic fibrosis (CF) is among the most common genetic diseases. Despite considerable improvement in survival recently with conventional therapies, patients with CF become increasingly debilitated and have markedly shortened life expectancies, mostly due to recurrent pulmonary infections.
The genetic defect in CF is well documented: mutations in a cell membrane chloride channel, the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR). The resulting defective cellular chloride transport has many consequences. CF patients produce very viscous mucous, the key consequences of which are exocrine pancreatic insufficiency and recurrent pulmonary infections. The latter leads to respiratory failure (
Treatment to date has generally been supportive: replacing the function of the defective ion channel has not yet been possible with small molecule therapeutics. Gene therapy would seem to offer a potentially useful therapeutic approach. However, despite great effort, CFTR gene delivery to the lungs has not yet succeeded in altering the course of the disease (
CF presents many obstacles to gene delivery that explain this situation. These include uncertainty as to which are the most appropriate cellular target for gene delivery, the best route of administration, viscous, neutrophil- and bacteria-rich mucous that both degrades vectors and prevents vectors delivered through the airways from reaching target epithelial cells, antigenicity of gene delivery vehicles, and the potential need to repeat gene delivery to compensate for loss of vector DNA and turnover of transduced cells (
Recombinant SV40-derived gene delivery vehicles (rSV40s) may help overcome some of these obstacles. These vectors integrate into the cell genome to provide permanent transduction and transduce most cell types very efficiently (
Despite considerable effort, genetic therapy for cystic fibrosis remains elusive. Some difficulties encountered in achieving this quest reflect the inherent pathophysiology of cystic fibrosis, while others are due to limitations of gene delivery technology. Application of recombinant SV40-derived gene delivery vectors (rSV40s) to this disease may circumvent some of these obstacles, e.g., the lack of neutralizing antibodies against these vectors may facilitate a potential need for repeated administration. To accommodate the large CFTR cDNA, we had to remove not only SV40
The current studies, undertaken
rSV40 genome constructs reported to date lacked the 2.6 kb
CFPAC cells (CFPAC-1, ATCC) make a mutated form of CFTR that is folded incorrectly (deletion of three nucleotides resulting in a phenylalanine-508 deletion), does not reach the cell membrane, and so is more rapidly degraded than wt CFTR (
Therefore, to evaluate more definitively the subcellular localization of the rSV40-CFTR delivered protein, confocal microscopic studies were done. Again, CFPAC cells were transduced with rSV40-CFTR or rSV40-HBS, or mock-transduced, then immunostained for CFTR and viewed using a confocal microscope (
An important measurable activity of CFTR is its function as a cell membrane chloride channel. To test whether rSV40-CFTR transduction of CFPAC cells produced a functional chloride channel, two different assays were used. In the first series of studies, mock- and rSV40-CFTR transduced cells were loaded with the fluorescent Cl-sensitive dye, N- (6-methoxyquinolyl) acetoethyl ester (MQAE, Sigma Chemical Co.) (
As an additional test of whether rSV40-CFTR could deliver a functional Cl- channel and to determine if channel activity could be restored in a different cell line, we performed 36Cl isotope tracer efflux assays on IB3–1 cells. CFTR-mutant IB3–1 cells (genotype ΔF508/W1282X) were infected with rSV40-CFTR at an MOI of 100. Mock-transduced T84 cells were the CFTR + control, mock-transduced IB3 cells were the CFTR −control. On day 10 post transduction, the cells were loaded with 5 μCi of 36Cl for 5 hours, and washed to remove excess isotope. The efflux rate was then measured at 30 second intervals for 4.0 minutes. After the final time point, the monolayer was carefully examined for integrity. Flasks with non-intact monolayers were eliminated from the experiment. Samples were counted for Cl36 activity. Transduction with rSV40-CFTR significantly increased Cl- channel activity by this assay, delivering ≈33% of wild type Cl- channel activity (P = 0.01), as compared to control T84 cells (
Having determined the functional expression of the CFTR channel
Two sets of independent experiments were performed with this model. In the initial Ps-bead challenge experiment matched groups of 5 Cftr−/− mice were treated with 4.0×107 particles of either rSV40-CFTR vector or the irrelevant rSV40-BUGT negative control via intra-tracheal injection and housed in SPF conditions. Due to the highly stable expression of rSV40 vectors it was possible to allow the mice to completely heal form the rSV40 intra-tracheal injection before performing the second intra-tracheal injection with the
To determine if these differences in weight lose were consistent with CFTR expression; RT-PCR assays to detect the SV40 driven human CFTR transcript were performed on lung tissue collected 4 days after bacterial challenge. As shown in
Further analysis of the lung compartment of these mice revealed that rSV40 mediated correction of the Cftr−/− mice, not only attenuated the weight loss phenotype, but it had also had an effect on the inflammatory cytokine profiles recovered from the broncho-alveolar lavages (BALs). While the cytokine levels in rSV40-CFTR rescued mice all trended lower, IL-1beta was statistically significantly lower (
In order to determine if this attenuated inflammatory profile in the BALs of rSV40-CFTR recued mice was accompanied by a reduction in the influx of neutrophils and lung pathology, a second set of aged matched mice were IT injected with either rSV40-CFTR or rSV40-BUGT. As in the first experiment described above, 8 weeks after rSV40 delivery, mice were challenged with Ps-bead slurry, albeit of a slightly lower CFU count due to preparation variations (3.0×106CFU/ml). Histopathological analysis of lung sections from this second cohort showed a dramatic reduction in the infiltration and inflammation of the lung tissue (
These studies were designed to test whether “gutless” rSV40 vectors carrying human CFTR cDNA could be effectively packaged and deliver CFTR expression after transduction, and whether the CFTR so provided constituted a functional chloride channel. It was important to ascertain that “gutless” rSV40 vectors carrying the 4.2 kb CFTR cDNA insert could be packaged by COS-7 cells. rSV40-CFTR was packaged by COS-7 cells at yields comparable to those obtained for other rSV40s that carry capsid genes: approximately 1011 IU/ml. Thus, the size of the vector genome, 5.5 kb, was within the packaging limits of this system. Some other vector systems require simultaneous cotransfection of packaging cells with multiple plasmids, or coinfection with helper viruses, in order to produce gutless vectors, but the effective packaging of a rSV40 lacking capsid genes in COS-7 cells indicates that the packaged rSV40 genomes need not carry SV40 capsid genes. The latter are expressed adequately, driven by their own promoter, by the COS-7 cells: neither helper virus nor cotransfection is involved. Preliminary studies show that SV40 capsid genes, under the control of the SV40 late promoter, are not expressed constitutively in COS-7 cells, but that the presence of a replicating rSV40 genome that includes the late promoter is sufficient to activate COS-7 transcription of the capsid genes
A possible explanation for this phenomenon is that replicating SV40 genomes titrate out a cellular repressor that inhibits transcription of integrated SV40 late genes (
CFPAC cells are a pancreatic adenocarcinoma line that carries the most common known loss of function mutation in the CFTR gene: ΔF508 (
Transduction with rSV40-CFTR delivered detectable CFTR protein by immunostaining
Most importantly, treatment with rSV40-CFTR provided a functional chloride channel activity that was lacking in both CFPAC and IB3 cells. Furthermore, channel function was demonstrated by two different assays of Cl- channel activity, both of which demonstrated similar functionality in the ion channel delivered by rSV40-CFTR. The level of Cl- channel activity in transduced cells was 1/3 to 1/2 of that seen in normal cells. Estimates of several investigators suggest that this level of Cl- channel activity is sufficient to avoid the most harmful consequences of mutation in CFTR (
CF gene therapy has stumbled at the transition between effective
Many hurdles remain before rSV40 gene delivery in CF can reach clinical fruition. Many issues, including vector safety and appropriate production procedures, all need to be considered. The unique ability of rSV40s to avoid eliciting neutralizing antibody has been demonstrated in rodents (
Beyond questions of effectiveness, issues relating to vector safety are important. To date, our preparations of rSV40 vectors have been free of
Conventional therapies have improved survival for patients with CF dramatically. Interesting new approaches continue to offer benefits, or potential benefits, to some such individuals (
Whether rSV40 vectors make a contribution here remains to be seen. But our data suggest that they may provide an additional gene delivery option in treating cystic fibrosis.
This vector utilizes a 4.2 kb (full length) human CFTR cDNA paired to 2 tandem SV40 early promoters. rSV40 genome constructs reported to date lacked the 2.6 kb
This vector utilizes a human bilirubin uridine diphosphate glucuronoside transferase (BUGT) cDNA paired to 2 tandem SV40 early promoters and was used as a control vector for
The resulting
CFPAC cells, a cystic fibrosis pancreatic adenocarcinoma cell line (ATCC, #CRL-1918) (
CFPAC cells were transduced with rSV40-CFTR at MOI = 100, or mock transduced. Control cells were TC7 cells, which are normal simian kidney cells (courtesy, Janet Butel, Baylor College of Medicine). To measure Cl- channel activity, a microplate assay technique was used, as described by West and Molloy 22. Specifically, 6d after transduction with rSV40-CFTR, CFPAC cells were plated in 96 well culture plates at a density of 104 cells/well. 48 hours after plating, cells were loaded overnight with 10 mM N-(6-methoxyquinolyl) acetoethyl ester (MQAE). The following day cells were washed with a chloride-containing buffer ( 2.4 mM K2HPO4; 0.6 mM KH2PO4; 10 mM HEPES; 10 mM dextrose; 1 mM MgSO4; 130 mM NaCl). This buffer was then replaced with a chloride-free buffer (2.4 mM K2HPO4; 0.6 mM KH2PO4; 10 mM HEPES; 10 mM dextrose; 1 mM MgSO4; 130 mM NaNO3), containing 10 μM forskolin. Repetitive fluorescence measurements were performed immediately using a Millipore Cytoflour 3050 plate reader (excitation; 360 nm, emission; 460).
IB3–1 cells were seeded at a density of 2×106 cells/T25 flask in LHC-8+ and left overnight in a 37°C humidified CO2 incubator. The next day monolayers had achieved subjectively between 60–70% confluence. T84 cells were also seeded as a supra-physiologic CFTR positive control and allowed to grow to ~70% at this time. The wells containing IB3–1 cells were assigned into either negative control plates that received PBS treatment or CFTR test plates that received either infected with viral rSV40-CFTR at an MOI of 100 (particles/cell). The virus containing media (LHC-8+) was left on the cells until day 5 and then was changed with 10 ml of fresh LHC-8+ medium. The LHC-8+ medium was replaced again on day 8.
On day 10 cells were loaded with 5mCi of 36Cl for 5 hours at 37°C. Each flask was then transferred into a modified 37°C dry heat incubator and placed upon a metal block heat sink. Each flask was washed 5 times with lactated Ringers solution (LRS) for 30 seconds/wash to remove excess isotope and the efflux rate was then measured at 30 second intervals for 4.0 minutes. All washes and the first efflux collection were obtained by removing the entire fluid volume (1.5 ml) from the flask with a disposable fine tipped transfer pipette, and replacing an equal amount of 37°C lactated Ringers solution (LRS). The replacement solution for second through eighth samples contained a combination of 2.5 mM forskolin, 250 mM 8-Br-cAMP, and 250 mM CPT-cAMP, added to increase intracellular levels of cAMP. At the conclusion of the final time point, the monolayer was carefully examined for integrity. Flasks with non-intact monolayers were eliminated from the experiment. Samples were mixed with CytoSafe scintillation fluid and counted for 36Cl activity. Statistical analyses were conducted by a two tailed t test, P(T≤t). The % change from the
In the challenge experiments, CFTRtm1Unc-TgN(FABPCFTR)#Jaw mice (gut-corrected CFTR knockout mice) (CFTR−/− )mice were treated intra-trachealy with rSV40-CFTR vector or rSV40-BUGT vector or phosphate-buffered saline (PBS), housed in specific pathogen-free (SPF) conditions for 8 weeks, and then challenged with 30 ul of an approximately 50% Pseudomonas agarose-bead mixture (as determined by 30-min gravity sedimentation) of OD600 2.0 containing ~ 3.0×106 cfu/ml. Mice were randomized with regards to injection order to avoid any unrecognized systematic error. Weights were recorded at time of challenge and at time of sacrifice on day 4. Histopathologic analysis of hematoxylin-eosin stained sections of formalin-fixed, paraffin embedded lung tissue samples taken at the time of sacrifice was performed by a pathologist blinded to the assignment of animals to the two groups.
To ensure the expression of hCFTR by the lungs, following intra-tracheal injections of rSV40-CFTR, lungs were collected from all the CFTR−/− mice. A 100mg of tissue sample was used to extract mRNA using the Qiagen (Valencia, CA) total RNA columns. For Reverse transcriptase first strand synthesis the Invitrogen Superscript III kit was used with the oligo(dt) primers and the optional DNase digestion according to the manufacture’s protocol. This was followed by a PCR using Eppendorf Taq polymerase master mix and gene specific primers for hCFTR (hCFTRfor_5′ aaacttctaatggtgatgacag, hCFTRrev_5′agaaattcttgctcgttgac) or B-actin (B-actin1_5′gctcgtcgtcgacaacggtc, Bactin2_5′caaacatgatctgggtcatcttctc). The no RT controls were subjected to the same PCR conditions and primers but in the absence of reverse transcriptase in the initial cDNA synthesis.
Mice were intra-trachealy injected with an rSV40 vector expressing an AU1 epitope tagged gene, 9 weeks post delivery mice where sacrificed and their lungs were inflated with a 50/50 mixture of PBS and OCT and subsequently frozen in OCT medium. For immunofluorescence, 10 um cryostat sections were processed for indirect immunofluorescence. Blocking was performed by 60 minutes incubation with 10% goat serum in 0.10 M PBS (pH 7.4). Then, cryostat sections were incubated with mouse FITC-labeled anti-AU1 (IgG2a; 1: 100) (Covance, Emeryville, CA) FITC and rabbit anti-human lysozyme (Accurate Chemical and Scientific Corp., Westbury, NY). Incubation with primary antibody was performed for 1 h and followed by incubation for 1 h with secondary antibody TRITC-conjugated goat anti-mouse IgG (Sigma, Saint-Louis, MO), diluted 1: 100. Incubations were at room temperature. Double immunofluorescence was performed as previously described (
The BAL fluid was retrieved from each animal via cannulation of the exposed trachea and gentle flushing of the lungs with two separate 1 ml aliquots of PBS. Aliquots were pooled for individual animals preceding centrifugation and separation of pelleted cells and supernatant. Cytospin cell preparations made with 200 μls of BAL were stained using Hema 3 (Biochemical Sciences, Swedesboro, NJ) differential stain and relative cell populations were determined using standard morphological criteria. Total cell numbers were calculated by counting the cells on the cytospin slide obtained from the 200 ul BAL aliquot. Assessments of cytokine profiles from the BAL were performed using a commercially available multiplexed kit(Biorad Mouse Multi-Cytokine Detection System; BioRad Laboratories) and the Bioplex Suspension Array System. Simultaneous measurement of several cytokines was performed. All assays were performedaccording to the manufacturer’s protocols. Cytokine concentrations were determinedutilizing Bioplex software with four-parameter data analysis. The sensitivity of the assay is less than 10pg/ml and has a range from 0.2–32,000 pg/ml with an inter and intra-assay CV of less than 10%.
This work was supported by grants AI48244, RR13156, AI41399 and R01HL69877 from the National Institutes of Health as well as by a fellowship from the Parker B Francis Foundation and the Diabetes and Endocrinology Research Center of the University of Massachusetts Medical School (supported by Grant P30 DK32520). The authors are grateful to Miss Maria Lamothe and Mr. Charles Ko for technical assistance. Dr. Janet S. Butel, Baylor College of Medicine, generously provided us with the original SV40 genomic constructs from which these vectors were derived. We are grateful to Dr. John Engelhardt for the human CFTR cDNA used in these studies.
pSV5 carries an SV40 genome from which the
CFPAC cells, a cystic fibrosis pancreatic adenocarcinoma cell line were plated in 4 well slides at a density of 105 cells/well. The cells were transduced with rSV40-CFTR, rSV40-HBS (negative control) at an MOI of ~3 or were mock-transduced. For (a) and (b), staining was visualized using an Olympus fluorescence microscope, and digitized (Spot Image Analysis Software, Diagnostic Instruments) using Macintosh computers. (a) composite of representative immunostained fields in cells treated as noted. (b) higher magnification of rSV40-CFTR-transduced and mock-transduced cells. (c) confocal microscopic examination of rSV-CFTR-transduced and control cells (as in (a)). CFPAC cells, transduced as in (a), were examined by confocal microscopy using a Biorad MR-60 confocal microscope.
CFPAC cells were transduced with rSV-CFTR at MOI = 100, or mock transduced. Control cells were TC7 cells, which are normal simian kidney cells (courtesy, Janet Butel, Baylor College of Medicine). To measure Cl- channel activity, a microplate assay technique was used, as described by West and Molloy 22. Data are presented as Δ fluorescence (
36Cl isotope tracer efflux assays – IB3 cells were plated at a density of 2×106 into T-25 flasks in LHC-8 media containing 10% FBS and 5% penicillin/streptomycin (LHC-8+) and allowed to grow overnight. The next day the media was changed with 10 ml of fresh LHC-8+ and cells were infected with rSV40-CFTR virus at an MOI of 100. Samples were mixed with CytoSafe scintillation fluid and counted for 36Cl activity. The % change from the
Shown are the means ± standard deviations of the percent changes in weight after Pseudomonas-agarose bead intra-tracheal challenge for the CFTR−/− mice in the rS40-CFTR group and in rS40-BUGT-treated control group. N=4 for each timepoint. *p≤0.05 difference between the two groups.
RT-PCR for Human CFTR mRNA was assayed from lungs 4 days after pseudomonas challenge. Lungs were homogenized and RNA was extracted to run RT-PCR reactions with human CFTR and B-actin primers; lanes 1–5 rSV40-CFTR, lanes 6–10 rSV40-BUGT. The ‘no reverse transcriptase’ controls were negative for both the CFTR and B-actin bands (data not shown)
Mice received 1.5×107 particles of a rSV40 vector with and AU1 epitope tag and were sacrificed 9 weeks post delivery. The far left frame is an H&E stain of the lung tissue, with black arrows depicting goblet cells. On the right are three fluorescence micrographs, the upper one using an antibody directed at lysozyme, to delineate the mucous-producing cells, the middle using an antibody against the AU1 tag, and the lower panels shows a merge of the two stains where the white arrows show representative doubly positive cells.
Cytokine levels in BALs of
The top panels show randomly selected, representative fields of hematoxylin-eosin stained lung sections from rS40-CFTR-treated CFTR−/− mice 4 days after Pseudomonas challenge. The bottom panels show similar fields from animals pretreated with rS40-BUGT. There were 5–6 animals in each group in this second experiment.
BAL Cell Counts after
Gross pathology scores in
| Vector Treatment | Lung Inflammation Score and Observations | |
|---|---|---|
| rSV40-CFTR | 0 | |
| rSV40-CFTR | 2 | multifocal, small, dilated airways surrounded by layer of PMNs and macrophages, exudate in lumens, minigranulomas |
| rSV40-CFTR | 0 | |
| rSV40-CFTR | 0 | |
| rSV40-CFTR | 2.5 | multifocal; bronchioles are surrounded by infiltrates but rarely invaded |
| |
|
|
| rSV40-BUGT | 3.5 | major bronchioles invaded and disintegrating epithelium and alveolar cells, granulomas, bulli |
| rSV40-BUGT | 1.5 | multifocal mild infiltrates and epithelial damage |
| rSV40-BUGT | 2 | multifocal; bronchioles are surrounded by infiltrates but rarely invaded. |
| rSV40-BUGT | 3.5 | multifocal infiltrates- severe, |
| rSV40-BUGT | 3.5 | multifocal infiltrates- severe, mixed populations, (“casts”; airway epithelium disintegration with sloughting epithelium into the lumen; exudate in airway “bulli |
| rSV40-BUGT | 2 | two foci infiltrates- mixed with PMN in lumen, numerous macrophages accumulating at point of infiltrate. |
|
|
|
|
p≤0.05 as determined by a Bonferonni corrected Kruskal-Wallis Test