Conceived and designed the experiments: SG EM ZB MH AC. Performed the experiments: SG EM YY SB DL NY HC AC. Analyzed the data: SG EM SB DL HB MK YG AC. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: NM. Wrote the paper: SG ZB MH AC.
Circulating nucleic acids (CNAs) offer unique opportunities for early diagnosis of clinical conditions. Here we show that microRNAs, a family of small non-coding regulatory RNAs involved in human development and pathology, are present in bodily fluids and represent new effective biomarkers.
After developing protocols for extracting and quantifying microRNAs in serum and other body fluids, the serum microRNA profiles of several healthy individuals were determined and found to be similar, validating the robustness of our methods. To address the possibility that the abundance of specific microRNAs might change during physiological or pathological conditions, serum microRNA levels in pregnant and non pregnant women were compared. In sera from pregnant women, microRNAs associated with human placenta were significantly elevated and their levels correlated with pregnancy stage.
Considering the central role of microRNAs in development and disease, our results highlight the medically relevant potential of determining microRNA levels in serum and other body fluids. Thus, microRNAs are a new class of CNAs that promise to serve as useful clinical biomarkers.
Specific clinical biomarkers have the potential to revolutionize diagnosis and treatment of various medical conditions, ranging from abnormal pregnancies to myocardial infarctions and cancer. In particular, a theme of current cancer research is the quest for sensitive biomarkers that can be exploited to detect early neoplastic changes. Ideally, biomarkers should be easily accessible such that they can be sampled non-invasively. Therefore biomarkers that can be sampled from body fluids, such as serum or urine, are particularly desirable. In recent years it has become clear that both cell-free DNA and mRNA are present in serum, as well as in other body fluids, and that these CNAs represent potential biomarkers
MicroRNAs are a recently discovered class of small non-coding RNAs that regulate gene expression and have a critical role in many biological and pathological processes
Although the total number of microRNAs remains controversial
Here we validate that microRNAs are present in body fluids and moreover, demonstrate that microRNA levels in serum reflect altered physiological conditions, such as pregnancy.
Serum samples were collected from 30 women: 10 in the first pregnancy trimester (6–12 weeks of gestational age), 10 in the third pregnancy trimester (34–41 weeks of gestational age) and 10 age-matched non-pregnant women. Eligibility for the study was limited to normal uncomplicated singleton pregnancies with no known fetal malformation. All women provided written informed consent and the local institutional review board approved the study. 8 ml of blood was collected from each woman directly into serum collection tubes (Greiner Bio-one, VACUETTE® Serum Tubes 455071). The whole blood was allowed to stand for about 1 h at RT before being centrifuged at 1800 g for 10 minutes at RT. The resultant serum was aliquoted into eppendorf tubes and stored at −80°C.
About 4 ml of urine samples were collected from each individual in a urine container. The urine was then aliquoted into eppendorf tubes and kept frozen at −80°C until it was used for RNA extraction.
100 µl serum or urine was incubated at 56°C for 1 h with 0.65 mg/ml Proteinase K (Sigma P2308). Two synthetic RNAs (IDT) were spiked-in as controls before acid phenol∶chloroform extraction and then RNA was ETOH precipitated ON at −20°C. Next, DNase treatment was performed to eliminate residual DNA fragments. Finally, after a second acid phenol∶chloroform extraction, the pellet was re-suspended in DDW and two additional synthetic RNAs were spiked-in as controls.
RNA was subjected to a polyadenylation reaction as described previously
We have developed a proprietary qRT-PCR based platform for evaluating microRNA levels that detects specifically mature microRNA molecules (see
A) Schematic representation of the qRT-PCR method. RNA is subjected to polyA polymerase reaction. Then, a universal RT reaction is performed that allows the amplification of all microRNAs as well as mRNAs. The PCR amplification is performed using a reverse primer complementary to part of the oligodT primer and a forward primer, which is homologous to a stretch in the microRNA sequence; in addition, the amplification reaction contains a TaqMan probe that covers part of the oligodT primer sequence and some nucleotides complementary to the 3′ sequence of the microRNA. B) Each synthetic RNA (hsa-let 7a, c & d) was subjected to three independent qRT-PCR amplifications, where in each reaction there were present primers specific to only one of the three family members. PCR amplification was observed only in the reaction where the primer matches the synthetic RNA. RNA amounts are described as percentages, each relative to the level observed in the reaction containing primers matching the synthetic microRNA. ND is non-detectable. C) All three synthetic microRNAs were mixed and subjected to qRT-PCR in the presence of the let-7d primer-probe set. In parallel, the same amount of synthetic let-7d as used in the mixture was subjected alone to qRT-PCR. These parallel PCR reactions were repeated using reducing concentrations of let-7d synthetic microRNA. At all tested concentrations of let-7d, it was amplified equivalently whether alone or in the presence of homologous family members. The CT of let-7d is proportional to the input microRNA amount. D) Reducing concentrations (100-0.03%) of total RNA extracted from liver tissue (Ambion Inc., No. 0360093B#) were mixed with total RNA extracted from brain tissue (Ambion Inc., No. 016P040305030A#) and the mixtures subjected to qRT-PCR, where each reaction contained a primer specific to hsa-miR-122a. Hsa-miR-122a was detected linearly, even in samples where only 0.03% liver RNA was spiked into brain RNA. When no liver RNA was introduced (100% brain RNA), hsa-miR-122a was not detected. E) The amounts of 32 different microRNAs in an RNA sample were examined on two independent occasions (by two different researchers) using the qRT-PCR platform (microRNA level is represented as CT value). The two profiles were within less than 1 CT difference of one another.
Finally, to validate the reproducibility of our methods, at two independent times, two different researchers subjected the same mix of 32 microRNAs to qRT-PCR. Similar levels of abundance were determined for each microRNA on both occasions, such that the two abundance profiles (for all 32 microRNAs) were within less than 1 CT difference of one another (
When we initiated this study, there had been no demonstration that microRNAs are present in cell-free body fluids. While this manuscript was in preparation, it was reported that microRNAs are detectable in serum
To validate that microRNAs are indeed reproducibly detectable in serum, RNA was extracted from the sera of two healthy unrelated individuals and the levels of highly abundant microRNAs examined (
A) microRNA levels in serum samples taken from 2 healthy individuals were measured. The levels of 18 different microRNAs (blue circles, cycle thresholds (CT) values) and the 4 synthetic RNA ‘spike-ins’ (in the lower left part of the graph) were found to be similar. B) To demonstrate that our extraction and evaluation methods can be applied to other body fluids, the same set of 20 microRNAs examined in serum were assessed in urine samples from 2 healthy individuals. Some microRNAs were undetectable in the urine samples and therefore are not shown. Notably, urine and serum samples demonstrate different microRNA abundance profiles.
In order for microRNAs in serum to be useful as clinical biomarkers, they must be stable for reasonable periods of time, and preferably during freeze-thaw cycles, to allow for routine processing of clinical samples. Therefore, we investigated the stability of serum microRNAs at room temperature and checked the influence of freeze-thaw cycles on serum microRNA levels. We found that the levels of different microRNAs in unfrozen serum do not change substantially over a 4 hour period at room temperature (
A) microRNA stability in serum samples was monitored by extracting RNA from serum samples kept for 1, 2 or 4 h at room temperature before freezing. The levels of 20 different microRNAs (blue circles), as well as of the 4 synthetic RNA ‘spike-ins’ (in the lower left part of the graph), were found to be similar across the 4 h time period. B) microRNA stability in serum samples was monitored by extracting RNA from serum samples before and after freezing. The levels of 20 different microRNAs (blue circles), as well as of the 4 synthetic RNA ‘spike-ins’ (in the lower left part of the graph), were found to be similar following re-freezing and re-thawing of the sample.
Finally, as a proof of concept, we investigated whether circulating microRNAs can be used to identify clinical conditions. It has been established that circulating maternal RNA contains placental embryonic RNA
Box plots comparing microRNA levels in the sera of 10 non pregnant women (A), 10 women in the first trimester (B), and 10 women in the third trimester (C). microRNA level is specified as 50-CT, where CT is the cycle threshold of the PCR reaction. Results were normalized by subtracting the global microRNA level in the sample (average CT of the 6 microRNAs chosen for normalization) from the level (CT) of each microRNA. A) The three placental microRNAs (miR-527, miR-520d-5p and miR-526a) are highly abundant in the sera of pregnant women and their levels rise as pregnancy progresses. Hsa-let-7d levels are also shown; this was one of the 6 microRNAs chosen for normalization as this microRNA exhibits similar abundance across the three groups. B) microRNA miR-141 and miR-149 levels are mildly upregulated during pregnancy.
Discrimination of pregnant women from non pregnant women based on microRNA levels in their sera. Blue circles represent non pregnant women and red triangles represent pregnant women. The location of each symbol in the plot represents the collective expression of all three microRNAs in a given serum. The y axis indicates the amount of mir-527, and the x axis indicates the average level of miR-520d-5p and miR-526a.
| microRNA | delta CT | fold change | p-value |
|
|
9.44 | 694 | 2.10E-07 |
|
|
9.28 | 622 | 1.20E-14 |
|
|
9 | 511 | 6.90E-08 |
|
|
7.36 | 164 | 8.10E-09 |
|
|
4.81 | 28 | 2.20E-06 |
|
|
4.81 | 27 | 2.80E-03 |
|
|
3.61 | 12 | 1.80E-04 |
|
|
3.1 | 8.6 | 3.30E-07 |
|
|
2.73 | 6.6 | 5.60E-04 |
|
|
2.47 | 5.5 | 1.10E-01 |
|
|
2.38 | 5.2 | 1.30E-04 |
|
|
2.35 | 5.1 | 7.60E-03 |
|
|
2.27 | 4.8 | 3.80E-03 |
|
|
2.16 | 4.5 | 1.90E-03 |
|
|
2 | 4.0 | 3.90E-04 |
|
|
1.9 | 3.7 | 2.60E-02 |
|
|
1.82 | 3.5 | 5.80E-02 |
|
|
1.5 | 2.8 | 3.50E-02 |
|
|
0.98 | 2.0 | 3.20E-02 |
|
|
0.92 | 1.9 | 6.00E-01 |
|
|
0.59 | 1.5 | 5.20E-01 |
|
|
0.39 | 1.3 | 6.90E-01 |
|
|
0.16 | 1.1 | 1.60E-01 |
|
|
0.11 | 1.1 | 8.70E-01 |
|
|
0.1 | 1.1 | 4.80E-01 |
|
|
−0.13 | 0.91 | 8.40E-01 |
For each microRNA, “delta CT” indicates the difference in median CT between the serum of pregnant women in the third trimester (n = 10) and non-pregnant women (n = 10). For each sample, the relative amount of the microRNAs was normalized by subtracting the average CT of the non-placenta-specific microRNAs. The fold change is the ratio of the median abundance in linear space, equal to the exponent (base 2) of the delta CT. P-values are calculated by a two-sided unpaired t-test.
While we were preparing these results for publication, another research group reported that hsa-miR-141 and hsa-miR-149 are present in serum and display increased abundance during pregnancy
The results of this study clearly uphold our basic hypothesis that microRNAs are present in bodily fluids and represent useful clinical biomarkers. Importantly, we have developed reliable methods for extracting microRNAs from bodily fluids and for evaluating their abundance. Moreover, we have demonstrated that microRNA serum levels reflect physiological conditions, such as pregnancy, and can even be used to determine pregnancy stage.
We identified previously a large subset of microRNAs that are expressed almost exclusively in the placenta
This proof of concept study reveals the potential of body fluid microRNAs to serve as practicable molecular markers for diverse physiological and pathological conditions, especially those where microRNAs have already been found to play a critical role, such as cancer. Moreover, we demonstrate here the ease and reliability of determining body fluid microRNA profiles and thus, pave the way for their wide application, both in the research laboratory and in the clinic.