Conceived and designed the experiments: AI AV. Performed the experiments: AV. Analyzed the data: AI AV. Wrote the paper: AI.
The linker histone H1 binds to the DNA in between adjacent nucleosomes and contributes to chromatin organization and transcriptional control. It is known that H1 carries diverse posttranslational modifications (PTMs), including phosphorylation, lysine methylation and ADP-ribosylation. Their biological functions, however, remain largely unclear. This is in part due to the fact that most of the studies have been performed in organisms that have several H1 variants, which complicates the analyses. We have chosen
Histone H1 is a linker histone, as it binds to the DNA that resides between two adjacent nucleosome particles (for review see
Histone H1 consists of a conserved globular domain, which is sufficient for the binding of H1 to nucleosomes
It is known that H1 from various organisms is posttranslationally modified at several positions (PTMs), including phosphorylation
In order to better study the importance as well as the evolutionary conservation of H1 PTMs, we decided to analyze H1 from
To develop a robust protocol that allows a parallel analysis of several samples of H1 from Drosophila embryos from different stages, we initially used embryos collected between 0 to 12 h after egg laying (a.e.l.). One of the major inconveniences when working with early embryos is the enormous amount of yolk present in the protein extracts. To circumvent this problem, nuclei are separated from the bulk of yolk proteins and subsequently extracted with perchloric acid. The resulting extract is highly enriched in histone H1 and HMG-D. After dialysis and freeze-drying, histone H1 can be easily purified by RP-HPLC. The use of HPLC for protein separation has a clear advantage over the use of SDS-PAGE: the isolated proteins remain in solution, and many proteases employed for MS analysis do not cleave efficiently when the substrate is embedded in a gel piece.
Purified H1 was digested with the endoprotease AspN, which hydrolyzes the peptide bond N-terminal of aspartic acid, and MALDI-TOF spectra were acquired in the linear, positive mode. As shown in
H1 from 0–12 h embryos was purified and digested with Asp-N. Digestion mixtures were desalted and analyzed by MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry in positive, linear mode. A) A typical spectrum has signals corresponding to all the expected peptides. * labels the signals corresponding to [M+2H]2+. B and C) Zooms of the spectrum shown in A encompassing the two regions where signals corresponding to modified peptides are found. B) Peaks of the N-terminus of the protein (5003.5 and 5132.8) and its phosphorylated forms (5083.8, 5213.1, 5294.8). C) C-terminus of the protein (6743.7) and its presumptive methylated form (6756.6). Red: MALDI-TOF, linear positive mode; black: MALDI-TOF, reflector positive mode. D) Assignment of the peaks in A-C.
In the N-terminus (
Because the acetylation can only be seen in the peptide 1–52 and not in 2–52, we conclude that H1 is acetylated at the amino terminus. This conclusion is also supported by digestion with other proteases (trypsine, Glu-C) and by the MS/MS analysis of peptides carrying the N-terminus.
The peak corresponding to a C-terminal peptide (aa 189–255) shows only one additional mass at a m/z value of 6758.3 (
In order to further study the potential methylation, we decided to map the amino acid position(s) in the C-terminus of H1 at which the mass shift is observed. However, the composition of the peptide (22 lysine, 18 alanine, 7 threonine, 6 valine, 5 serine, 5 proline, 2 isoleucine, 1 glycine and 1 aspartic acid residue) and its size (6.7 kDa), made it very difficult to map the site of modification using conventional proteases or tandem mass spectrometry.
Therefore we decided to purify the peptide by RP-HPLC and subsequently perform a limited carboxypeptidase Y digestion on the purified peptides. The reaction products were then analyzed using MALDI-TOF MS. Carboxypeptidase Y removes the C-terminal amino acid of a peptide in a processive manner thereby resulting in a series of peaks that differ by the mass of one aminoacid. However, as the reaction rate is highly dependent on the nature of the removed amino acid, the resulting ladder is not continuous and only the peptides that contain an amino acid at the C-terminus, which is slowly cleaved by carboxypeptidase Y, can be seen.
In our conditions, the peptides corresponding to the peptide 189–255 could be separated from its potentially methylated form by RP-HPLC (
A) Separation of the peptides produced by AspN digestion of H1 from 0–12 h embryos over a C18 column. Continous line: absorbance at 214 nm; dashed line: eluent composition expressed as percentage of eluent B. B and C) The purified peptides 189–255 and its methylated form were partially digested with carboxypeptidase Y. The digestion mixtures were desalted and analysed by MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry in the linear, reflector mode. Zooms are shown. In both panels, the upper spectrum corresponds to the unmodified form and the lower, to the modified one. The results indicate that the methylated residue is in the stretch 215–224. B) Region displaying the largest peptides where identical mass in both samples is detected. C) Region displaying the smallest peptides where a mass difference between both samples is detected. For the region 215–224 no signals are present in the spectra. D) H1 was isolated from different sources, digested with Asp-N, desalted and analysed by MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry in the linear, positive mode. Zoom of the region containing 189–255 is shown. Magenta: 2–3 h embryos, green: 12–15 h embryos, grey: 0–12 h embryos, black SL2 cells. The proportion unmethylated (6744.4)/methylated (6758.3) is identical in all the embryonic samples, whereas no methylated species can be detected in the SL2 cells. The peak with a m/z value of 6767.3 corresponds to a sodium adduct of the unmethylated form. E) The existence of the polymorphism V217I could explain our observations. Upper panel: a stretch of the DNA sequence of a H1 gene coding for the Val allele is shown (accession number: NM_165380). The numbers indicate the base position with respect to the transcription start. A SfcI restriction site is underlined. The corresponding translated sequence is shown underneath. The numbers indicate the aminoacid position respect to the mature protein. The long lines represent the fragment of DNA sequence amplified by PCR, the arrows, the SfcI restriction sites and the short lines at the bottom, the expected fragments after SfcI digestion. The lower panel represents the same but for a H1 gene coding for the Ile allele (for instance, accession number: NM_1032208). The shift 688 G->A results in the lost of a SfcI restriction site. F) The polymorphism Val217Ile is present in the fly population. A stretch of the coding sequence of H1 (606–806) was amplified from fly and SL2 cells genomic DNA. The products were digested with SfcI and the resulting fragments were analysed by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. As control, parallel incubations with no enzyme were performed. In the sample from SL2 cells, only the expected bands for the allele Val are observed (60 and 123 bp, the 18 bp bands ran out of the gel), whereas in the sample from the flies, the pattern fits with the existence of both the Val (60 and 123 bp) and the Ile (60 and 141 bp) alleles.
We next wondered whether the ratio of the wild-type peptide and the shifted one change during development. In order to do this, we isolated H1 from embryos at different developmental stages (2–3 h, 3–6 h, 6–9 h, 9–12 h and 12–15h a.e.l.). A quantitative comparison of the relative intensities of the two peaks did not change during embryonic development (
One possible explanation could be the existence of different isoforms that differ by the mass of one methyl group. Indeed, several polymorphisms in the sequence of
As mentioned above, histone H1 in 0–12 h embryos is phosphorylated at the N-terminus. In order to enhance the detection of putative phosphorylated species, MALDI-TOF spectra in the negative, linear mode were acquired from H1 after digestion with AspN. However, even under conditions where phosphopeptides are preferentially ionized not more than 2 phosphate groups can be detected in the peptide 1–52. This is also the only region of the protein appears to be stably phosphorylated (
H1 from 0–12 h embryos was isolated and digested with AspN (A), trypsin (B) or Glu-C (C, D). Digests were desalted and MALDI-TOF spectra were acquired in the linear (A, C, D) or reflector (B) modes. For each sample, spectra in the positive (upper spectrum on each panel) and negative (lower spectrum on each panel) were recorded. Zooms of the interesting regions are shown. A) In the negative mode, no more phosphorylation states for 1–52 mode are detected, respect to the positive mode. B) After digestion with trypsin, mono- and diphosphorylation are detected in 1–21 and no modification (apart from oxidation) is present in 38–57. C, D) After digestion with Glu-C, no PTM is detected for 21–61 (only oxidation, C), however 1–20 appears clearly un-, mono and diphosphorylated (D).
To narrow down the number of possible modified sites, H1 was digested with other proteases and the resulting digestion products were analyzed by MALDI-TOF in positive and negative mode. Trypsin digests show that a significant proportion of the peptide 1–21 is mono- and diphosphorylated, whereas no modification apart from oxidation is observed in 38–57 (
Because the peptide 1–21 has 6 residues (4 Ser and 2 Thr,
H1 from 0–12 h embryos was purified, digested with trypsin, and submited to β-elimination followed by 1,4-addition of 2-mercaptoethanol. The resulting crude was desalted and the different forms of the peptide 1–21 were sequenced by ESI-MS/MS. A) Scheme showing the peptide 1–21 and the numbering of the b and y ions. The residues susceptible of phosphorylation are highlighted in red. B) TOF-MS spectrum of the sample. The double charged ions corresponding to 1–21, its modified forms and sodium adducts are indicated. Note that, due to the chemical treatment of the sample, the mass difference between the unmodified and the monomodified form is 60 instead of 80. C, D) Zooms of the product ion spectra for the unmodified (lower), monomodified (middle) and dimodified (upper) forms. * labels the ions with one modification; ** labels the ions with two modifications. C) For y11 only no modified ions are detected in both the mono- and dimodified peptide 1–21, which indicates that there is no detectable phosphorylation at T18. Therefore, the presence of monomodified y12 can only be due to phosphorylation at S10. The pattern of the b13 and b14 ions in the spectra of the mono- and dimodified species corroborate this assumption. In the spectrum of the diphosphorylated population, the presence of only monomodified y12 and y13 indicates that one of the two phosphate groups on each molecule is at S10. Additionally, the signal of dimodified y14 reveals the existence of a subpopulation of the peptide 1–21 containing phosphate groups at S10 and S8 simultaneously. Moreover, the higher relative intensity of dimodified vs. monomodified ions y15 and y16 respect to the same ratio for y14 suggests the presence of a species with simultaneous S10 and T7 phosphorylation. D) There is a small proportion of H1monophosphorylated at S1 and/or S3, as revealed by the intensities of b6, b6*, b7 andb7*. In the diphosphorylated population there is also modification at S1 and/or S3, however, simultaneous phosphorylation at S1 and S3 in the same molecule cannot be detected.
Judging from the MS/MS spectra of the differentially modified peptides, we conclude that there is no detectable phosphorylation outside amino acids 1–10 and that most of the phosphorylation is found at position S10 in the singly- as well as the doubly phosphorylated peptide (see
In summary at least two subpopulations of diphosphorylated H1 can be distinguished:
i) one of the phosphate groups is at S10 and the other at S1/S3; However, as mentioned above, we could not distinguish between S1 and S3 modification, but from the b ions (b6, b7 in
ii) one of the phosphate groups is at S10 and the other at T7/S8. The presence of a dimodified y14 together with the absence of dimodified y12 and y13 indicates the existence of a phosphate group at S8. The apparent higher dimodified vs. monomodified ratio of y15 and y16 when compared to y14 suggests that there is also part of the population that is diphosphorylated at S10 and T7.
The analysis of the sodium adducts of the mono- and diphosphorylated forms yield the same result.
Once known that H1 in
The relative intensities of the MALDI-TOF spectra indicate a decrease in the proportion of monophosphorylated protein in the oldest embryos, independently of the protease (AspN or trypsin) used and the mode of spectra acquisition (linear or reflector, positive or negative). An example is shown in
Histone H1 from 2–3 h, 3–6 h, 6–9 h, 9–12 h and 12–15 h was isolated and digested with trypsin. A) Zoom of two MALDI-TOF spectra acquired in the reflector positive mode are shown as examples. The upper spectrum corresponds to the 12–15 h old embryos, the lower to the 3–6 h ones. Note the different intensity of the signal at 2078. B) To compare the proportion of monophosphorylated H1 between the different stages, the area of the clusters corresponding to unmodified 1–21 (both proton and sodium adducts) and the monophosphorylated form (only proton adduct, sodium adduct not detected) was calculated for H1 from staged embryos. For each sample, the relative area of the monophosphorylated species (Arel) was calculated by division of the area of the monophosphorylated species through the total area (unmodified+monophosphorylated). The results of two independent biological replicates are shown. The error bars indicate the maximum and the minimum obtained values. C) Scheme showing the peptide 1–21 and the numbering of the b and y ions. The residues susceptible of phosphorylation are highlighted in red. D and E) H1 from 3–6 h and 12–15 h old embryos was purified, digested with trypsin, submitted to chemical modification (β-elimination and Michael addition) and finally, the forms of 1–21 were sequenced by ESI-MS/MS. Zooms of the product ions of the monomodified species are shown. * labels the modified species. D) The relative intensities of y12 and y12* indicate that the 12–15 h old embryos have less proportion of S10 phosphorylation than the younger embryos. E) The relative intensities of the b and b* ions suggest that monophosphorylated H1 from 12–15 h old embryos contains more proportion of S1 and/or S3 phosphorylation than the sample from the younger embryos.
To determine if the loss of phosphorylation occurs selectively at a certain position, we determined the site of modification by ESI-MS/MS 3–6 h and 12–15 h embryos. The product ion spectra of the ion containing the monophosphorylated H1 peptide in both samples show noticeable changes in the relative intensities of unmodified vs. modified y12 (
In summary, during the first hours of development, the proportion of H1 phosphorylated at S10 is decreasing.
We present here a detailed analysis of PTMs in H1 from
Together with phosphorylation, lysine acetylation, methylation and formylation have been found in mammalian H1, but very little about their biological function is known
Finally, we would like to point out that the existence of polymorphisms in the protein sequence can lead to erroneous interpretations. Diverse couples of amino acids have a similar chemical structure that differs only in the presence of a methyl group. This is the case for glycine and alanine, alanine and valine, valine and leucine or isoleucine, aspartic and glutamic acid, asparagine and glutamine, serine and threonine. Thus, if the peptides are not fully sequenced with all fragment ions visible, it is not possible to assess if the observed 14 units mass difference is due to a methyl group modifying a lysine or arginine residue or to a polymorphism in the protein sequence. Additionally, the mass difference between lysine and arginine is very similar to the mass difference between an unmodified and dimethylated lysine and can only be distinguished with mass spectrometers of very high resolution. Existence of these kind of substitutions in human H1.2 and H1.4 have already been reported
In summary, we have analyzed the entire sequence of
Embryos were washed from the agar plates with tap water and dechorionated by stirring for 1 min in diluted bleach solution (23 ml bleach 6–14% active chlorine in 100 ml final volume), rinsed with 1 l 0.12 M NaCl containing 0.04% Triton X-100 (v/v) and washed thoroughly with tap water. 4–5 g dechorionated embryos were dehydrated by immersion in 70% ethanol during 5 min at room temperature, decanted and stored at −80°C.
Nuclei from the frozen embryos were prepared in a similar way as described before
Nuclei were transferred to 1.5 ml tubes and extracted with diluted HClO4 as described previously
SL2 cells were grown at 26°C in Schneideŕs
H1 was purified by HPLC over a Jupiter C4 (nucleosil 5 µm, 300 Å 150×1 mm) column (Phenomenex) with 0.05% TFA as eluent A and 0.065% TFA/84% acetonitrile as eluent B. Elution was performed with a 3-steps gradient (31%B during 2 min, 31%B to 37% B in 10 min, 37% B to 45% B in 30 min) at 50 µl/min flow rate and absorbance at 214 nm was monitored. 50 µl fractions were collected. Before proceeding to the next sample, column was washed with 100% B during 10 min and reequilibrated with 31% B. For each run, fractions containing H1 were pooled, concentrated to dryness (speed-vac), reconstituted in 10–30 µl 0.1% TFA and stored at −20°C.
HPLC-purified H1 (amount corresponding to 30 mAU/min in the chromatogram) was digested in a reaction volume of 20 µl overnight at 25°C with 80 ng AspN (Roche) in 0.1 M Tris pH = 8.5; or at 25°C with 50 ng GluC (Roche) in 25 mM NH4HCO3 or at 37°C with 0.4 µg trypsin (Promega) in 50 mM NH4HCO3. Except otherwise stated, reaction crudes were quenched with 2 µl TFA.
3 µl each quenched digestion crude were diluted with 7 µl 0.1% TFA and desalted with ZipTip µ-C18 (Millipore) according manufactureŕs instructions. Samples were eluted from the resin with 2 µl 50% acetonitrile/0.1% TFA, mixed with an identical volume of matrix (50% acetonitrile/0.3% TFA, saturated of α-cyano-hydroxycinnamic acid) and spotted immediately onto a stainless steel MALDI-TOF target plate. Spectra were acquired on a Voyager DE STR workstation (Applied Biosystems).
Integration of the signals corresponding to each peptide (isotopic cluster area) was automatically performed by the Data Explorer software (Applied Biosystems) excluding all the peaks whose signal-to-noise ratio was smaller than 4.
Quenched AspN digestions were pooled to get approximately 300 µl final volume and concentrated to ca. 80 µl. Formic acid was added (final concentration: 0.1%) and 40 µl were fractionated on a Gemini C18 column run at 0.2 ml/min. Eluent A was 0.05% TFA and eluent B 0.065% TFA/84 % acetonitrile; gradient from 4% B to 25% B in 60 min. 0.1 ml fractions were collected. Absorbance at 214 nm was monitored and 2 µl each fraction were used to analyze its composition by MALDI-TOF MS in positive, linear mode.
Fractions corresponding to the unmethylated and monomethylated forms of 189–255 were collected, concentrated to dryness and reconstituted in 1 µl reaction mix (50 mM Tris pH = 6.8 and 40 ng/µl carboxypeptidase Y). 5 µl each reaction were quenched with 5 µl 2.5 % TFA after 0.5 h incubation and the rest, after 2.5 h. Quenched digestion mixtures were directly desalted and analyzed by MALDI-TOF as indicated above.
For each sample, 1-2 tryptic digests (not quenched) were pooled and divided in 5 µl aliquots. Chemical modification was performed as described by Arrigoni et al.
Tandem mass spectrometry analyses were performed on a Qstar XL hybrid quadrupole TOF spectrometer (Applied Biosystems). For sample ionization, either a nanospray ion source (Protana) or a Nanomate (Advion) were employed. For each spectrum, measurements during 5 min were accumulated. Acquisition was performed in the positive mode and the collision energy was manually adjusted during the measurements, using the same values during the same time for all the samples.
Spectra were manually interpreted.
Nuclei from 0.6 g
Nuclei from SL2 cells or from embryos were lysated in 0.5 ml proteinase K buffer (50 mM Tris pH = 8.5, 10 mM EDTA pH = 8.0, 0.1 M NaCl and 1% SDS). 20 µg RNAse A were added to each sample, followed by 30 min incubation at 30°C. Then, 40 µg proteinase K were added and digestion was allowed to proceed at 37°C overnight. After a wash with 1 vol phenol (saturated with TE) and another wash with phenol/chloroform/isoamylalcohol (50/49/1), DNA was precipitated with 1.5 ml absolute ethanol in the presence of 50 µl 3 M sodium acetate. DNA was pelleted (centrifugation at 16000 g, 2 min, r.t.), washed twice with 70% ethanol, reconstituted in water and stored at −20°C.
0.1 µg genomic DNA was amplified with T4 Taq Polymerase (NEB) according manufactureŕs instructions in a 50 µl reaction containing 1.0 µM each primer (forward:
0.5 µg PCR product (purified with the Illumina GFX PCR DNA and gel band purification kit, Amersham, according manufactureŕs instructions) were digested with 5 U SfcI (NEB) in 50 µl reaction, according manufactureŕs instructions. To reach the complete digestion, after 1.5 h incubation at 37°C, 5 U SfcI more were added to each reaction and the incubation was prolonged overnight at 30°C. Reaction products were analyzed on an 8% acrylamide gel with ethidium bromide staining.
We would like to thank all members of the Imhof lab for critical comments on the manuscript and H1 containing nuclear extracts. We would furthermore like to thank Lars Israel, Andreas Hochheimer and Tilman Schlunck for expert technical assistance.