The Rieger syndrome is an autosomal dominant disease characterized by ocular, craniofacial, and umbilical defects. Patients have mutations in PITX2, a paired-bicoid homeobox gene, also involved in left/right polarity determination. In this study we have identified a family of genes for enzymes responsible for hydroxylizing lysines in collagens as one group of likely cognate targets of PITX2 transcriptional regulation. The mouse procollagen lysyl hydroxylase (Plod)-2 gene was enriched for by chromatin precipitation using a PITX2/Pitx2-specific antibody. Plod-2, as well as the human PLOD-1 promoters, contains multiple bicoid (PITX2) binding elements. We show these elements to bind PITX2 specifically in vitro. The PLOD-1 promoter induces the expression of a luciferase reporter gene in the presence of PITX2 in cotransfection experiments. The Rieger syndrome causing PITX2 mutant T68P fails to induce PLOD-1–luciferase. Mutations and rearrangements in PLOD-1 are known to be prevalent in patients with Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, kyphoscoliosis type (type VI [EDVI]). Several of the same organ systems are involved in Rieger syndrome and EDVI.
Studies of the autosomal-dominant Rieger syndrome first suggested that a single gene could be involved in the development of eye, tooth, and abdominal organs (
The PITX genes are members of the bicoid class of the homeodomain proteins. These have a lysine residue at position nine of the third helix and are especially noteworthy for a role in both DNA and RNA binding (
PITX2 was first identified by positional cloning of the 4q25 locus, but only 40% of patients diagnosed with classical Rieger syndrome have PITX2 mutations (
Chromatin precipitation is a direct method for in vivo detection of target genes. It has been used successfully to identify: ultrabithorax target genes (
Here we identify some members of the procollagen lysyl hydroxylase (PLOD) family, genes for enzymes that hydroxylate lysines in collagens, as cognate targets for Pitx2/PITX2, by chromatin precipitation. The hydroxylysine residues have two important functions: as attachment sites for carbohydrate units and to provide stability to intermolecular cross-links. Cross-links involving hydroxylysine-derived aldehydes are more stable than those involving lysine-derived aldehydes (
Point mutations and rearrangements in the human PLOD1 are causative for the Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, kyphoscoliosis type, type VI (EDVI), characterized by ocular, muscular, and skin defects (
We have previously characterized the Pitx2-specific antibody P2R10 (
We screened bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) libraries by PCR and BAC clones in pBeloBac11 were obtained from Research Genetics (mouse Plod-2, 249B6; human PLOD-1, 33A19). BAC DNA was prepared and sequenced directly as described previously (
Oligodeoxyribonucleotides (see
Mouse mRNA was prepared from freshly dissected mouse tissues using a Micro Fast Track kit (Invitrogen). Human cDNAs were purchased from CLONTECH Laboratories, Inc. 20-μl reverse transcription (RT) reactions were performed using a semianchored oligo-dT primer and Superscript II reverse transcriptase (GIBCO BRL) according to the recommendations of the manufacturer. The cDNAs were diluted four or six times in 10 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.5, and 1 μl was used per PCR reaction. The primers used for PCR are listed in
An ABI Prism Sequence Detector 7700, with the program Sequence Detector v1.7, was used for real-time PCR experiments, performed according to the recommendations of the manufacturer. Primers (
Parts of the PLOD-1 promoter sequence were cloned into the luciferase gene expression vector pGL3 (Promega). Construct A, a 3,140-bp Apa1 fragment containing 10 bicoid elements and ending 37 bp upstream of exon 1 (positions 265–3404, in GenBank/EMBL/DDBJ accession no. AF081786; see
CHO cells were cultured in DME supplemented with 5% FBS and penicillin/streptomycin in 60-mm dishes and transfected by electroporation. CHO cells were mixed with 2.5 μg of expression plasmids, 5 μg of reporter plasmid, and 0.5 μg of CMV–β-galactosidase plasmid plated in 60-mm culture dishes and then fed with 5% FBS and DME. Electroporation of CHO cells was at 360 V and 950 μF; cells were fed 24 h before transfection. HeLa cells were mixed with 2.5 μg of expression plasmids, 5 μg of reporter plasmid, and 0.5 μg of CMV–β-galactosidase plasmid. HeLa cells were electroporated at 220 V and 960 μF (Bio-Rad Laboratories), plated in 60-mm culture dishes, and fed with 5% FBS and DME as described previously (
The nucleoprotein complexes of E14 mouse heads were immunoenriched by using a Pitx2-specific antibody (
We screened a mouse genomic library and retrieved a BAC clone containing the Plod-2 gene. We sequenced 2,551 bp upstream of where the 5′ end of the published cDNA sequence starts. Here we discovered several sites shown previously to bind
We also studied the human PLOD-1 promoter, since the sequence was available (GenBank/EMBL/DDBJ accession no. AF081786). Approximately 3 kb upstream of the PLOD-1 5′ untranslated region we detected 10 bicoid elements (TAATCCC). We confirmed the in vitro binding properties of some of these elements (C, E, and G) by EMSA, using human PITX2 protein (
We proceeded to clone the PLOD-1 promoter in a luciferase reporter gene vector. We characterized the response to PITX2 by cotransfecting the PLOD-1–luciferase construct with a PITX2 expression vector. In CHO cells, the PLOD-1 261 construct containing 10 bicoid elements was activated 20-fold by PITX2A (
We wanted to study which tissues Pitx2 was coexpressed in with Plod-1 and Plod-2. We assayed this by RT-PCR of mRNA isolated from various mouse tissue (
The PCR primers for Pitx2 were designed to detect most known isoforms (see Materials and Methods). First, we could confirm that Pitx2, Plod-1, and Plod-2 are coexpressed in the tissue used to create the chromatin precipitation library, mouse E14.5 heads (
We compared the reported clinical manifestations of Rieger syndrome and EDVI. We used the database Online Mendelian Inheritance in Man (available at http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/omim/) textbooks (e.g.,
Several direct and indirect lines of evidence now support the theory that the Plod genes belong to the cognate targets for Pitx2. (a) We were able to enrich for the Plod-2 gene ∼170-fold in a chromatin precipitation assay using a Pitx2/PITX2-specific antibody. This antibody does not cross-react with PITX1 or PITX3 (
It is also interesting to point out that Pitx2 is expressed in mouse aorta smooth muscle and some EDVI patients have aortic defects (
Our finding that PITX2 regulates PLOD-1 differently in different cellular backgrounds is indicative of the dependence of cofactors for correct function of a homeobox gene. The most appealing model for in vivo specificity of homeobox genes is probably the binding site selection model, in which cofactors define appropriate DNA binding site and later fine-tune expression levels (
Some mouse tissues express Plod-1 and Plod-2 in the absence of Pitx2 (adult spleen and E7 whole embryo). It may be that another Pitx family member regulates the Plod genes in these tissues. Perhaps more likely is that Pitx2 serves as a modifier of gene expression, as is known to be the case in the regulation of prolactin by PIT-1 and PITX2 (
This study was supported by grants from the National Institutes of Health (DE09170 and EY12384 to J.C. Murray); the National Institute of Dental and Craniofacial Research (DE13941-01 to B.A. Amendt); and the American Heart Association (9960299Z to B.A. Amendt); and a postdoctoral research fellowship was supported by the Fight for Sight research division of Prevent Blindness America (PD99018 to T.A. Hjalt).
Primers Used
| Gene | Forward (name) | Reverse (name) | Annealing temperature | Size |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| bp | ||||
| Primer pairs for BAC library screening | ||||
| Plod-2 | AGAGGCGGTGATGGAATGAACA (b18-s2) | CTACAAAACACTCGGTAAACAAGAT (b18-15) | 63°C | 121 |
| PLOD-1 | CCTGGGGCTGCTCTAAGTGC (p1-21) | CCCTGCCGTCTCCCTCCCTTCTCT (p1-8) | 68°C | 232 |
| Primer pairs for RT-PCR | ||||
| Pitx2 | GCCAGCAAGGAAAGAATGAGGAT (Pitx2-1) | CGTAGACACTTGGGGACATTCCTT (Pitx2-6) | 67°C | 950 |
| PITX2 | CCGAGGACCCGTCTAAGAAGAAGC (PITX2-5) | GCATACTGGCAAGCACTCAGGT (PITX2-2) | 67°C | 709 |
| Plod-1 | GGGAGGACTGGAGTGTGGAT (m1-10) | CAGGTTCTGGAAGATTCGGCAGCGAT (m1-11) | 67°C | 451 |
| Plod-2 | CAATTACACTGTGAAGGTTCTTGGTC (b18-7) | GCATAGCCAATAAAGCCTCCAGAAT (b18-rt) | 67°C | 333 |
| PLOD-1 | CAGATGGCTACTATGCCCGTTC (h1x59) | CAAAGTGCTCCATCTCCTCCAC (h1x63) | 67°C | 437 |
| PLOD-2 | GACCAGAAGAAAATCTAAGTCAAGC (h2x29) | AGTTCCTTTCATTCATCTCTGAT (h2x25) | 67°C | 359 |
| Oligodeoxyribonucleotides for EMSAs (only sense strand shown) | ||||
| Bicoid | ACGGCCCATCTAATCCCGTG | |||
| PLOD-1 C | AAATATGAAATAATCCCACA | |||
| PLOD-1 H | CTCACACCTGTAATCCCAGC | |||
| PLOD-1 J | CACATGCCTGTAATCCCAGC | |||
| PLOD-2 C | ATTTTTGTTTTCATCCCTAAACACAAA | |||
| PLOD-2 E | TTTACACTTTTAGTCCCAGGATTTAAA | |||
| PLOD-2 F | CATAGACATACTAATCAAAACCCAAAG | |||
| PLOD-2 G | TGGCTGCTCTTAAGCCCAAAATCATGA | |||
| Primer pairs for quantitative PCR | ||||
| 18S-rDNA | AGCCTATTCTTTTTACTGGCTTGG (18S1F) | GGAAGCGTGGCTCGGG (18S1R) | ||
| Prolactin | CCTGCTGTTCTGCCAAAATGT (TMPL-1) | CGGAGAGAAGTCTGGCAGTCA (TMPL-2) | ||
| Plod-2 | CAGAAGGAACAGCTGGGAGTG (TMP1F) | GTGGTGACTGCGAGGGCTT (TMP1RN) | ||
| TacMan probe | ACAAGCGCCTACTCAGCCAAGCAGAC (TMm2-1) | |||
Enrichment Test by Real-Time PCR
| Ct control | Ct enriched | ΔCt | Enrichment (fold) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18S | 16.33 ± 0.04 | 18.22 ± 0.07 | Down 1.89 | NA |
| Plod-2 | 32.88 ± 0.30 | 29.76 ± 0.09 | Up 3.12 | 32 |
| Prolactin | 21.45 ± 0.03 | 19.73 ± 0.04 | Up 1.72 | 12 |
Clinical Features of Rieger and Ehlers-Danlos Syndromes
| Clinical manifestations | Rieger syndrome | EDVI |
|---|---|---|
| Ocular | ||
| Glaucoma | Yes | Yes |
| Microcornea | Yes | Yes |
| Cornea plana | Yes | Yes |
| Blue sclera | No | Yes |
| Fragile eyes/corneas | No | Yes |
| Iris hypoplasia | Yes | No |
| Iridocorneal adhesions | Yes | No |
| Myopia | No | Yes |
| Dental | ||
| Tooth abnormalities | Yes | Yes |
| Abdominal | ||
| Inguinal hernia | Yes | Yes |
| Umbilical hernia | Yes | Yes |
| Omphalocele | Yes | No |
| Skin hyperflexibility | No | Yes |
| Colon rupture | No | Yes |
Clone B18 is immunoenriched by a Pitx2-specific antibody and hybridizes to single bands in a genomic Southern analysis. (A) The insert of clone B18 from the chromatin precipitation library was labeled and used to probe a filter with 30,000 plaques of nonamplified immunoenriched library. At least five strong signals are apparent and indicate an enrichment factor of 165. (B) Southern blot of total mouse DNA digested with PstI (lane 1) and EcoRI (lane 2).
The proximal promoter sequences of PLOD-1 and Plod-2. The proximal promoter DNA sequences of the human PLOD-1 (A) and mouse Plod-2 (B) are shown. PITX2 binding elements are in bold. The corresponding binding site names (A–J and A–H) are listed on the right side. The transcriptional start site of Plod-2 is not mapped, for reference purposes the 5′-most nucleotide of the cDNA (available from GenBank/EMBL/DDBJ under accession no. NM_011961) is used as +1. Bicoid-like and bicoid elements are in bold and boxed. In A, ApaI restriction sites are underlined. CAAT and TAATAA sequences are underlined with thick lines. These sequence data are available from GenBank/EMBL/DDBJ under accession nos. AF081786 (PLOD-1) and AF283255 (Plod-2).
Rieger syndrome mutant PITX2 T68P fails to upregulate PLOD-1–luciferase fusion constructs. The PLOD-1 promoter was fused to a luciferase reporter gene and assayed for activation by PITX2A-T68P. (A) Location of the mutation T68P in helix 2 of PITX2. A lysine residue in helix 3, important for binding, is underlined. (B) CHO cells. (C) HeLa cells.
PLOD-1 and Plod-2 promoter elements bind PITX2 in vitro. (A) EMSA of PITX2 protein incubated with radioactively labeled double stranded oligodeoxyribonucleotide probes designed from the PLOD-1 promoter. Bic,
PITX2 upregulates PLOD-1–luciferase fusion constructs. The PLOD-1 promoter was fused to a luciferase reporter gene and assayed for activation by PITX2A. (A) CHO cells. (B) HeLa cells.
Coexpression of Pitx2 and Plod-1/Plod-2. (A) RT-PCR with Pitx2, Plod-1, and Plod-2 primers on mRNA prepared from E14.5 mouse heads, E13.5 mouse eyes, and adult human skeletal muscle. (B) RT-PCR with various embryonic and adult mouse tissues.